‘An ever-changing situation’: TV ad buyers adapt to live sports hiatus
Television’s most prized programming — live sports — is off the air for the foreseeable future. With March Madness canceled, the NBA, NHL, MLB and Nascar seasons put on hold and events such as the Masters and the Kentucky Derby postponed, advertisers and TV networks are scrambling to make up for the lost ad impressions.
“Billions of dollars of the most sought-after inventory just evaporated, forcing advertisers and media planners to find alternatives quickly,” said Doug Rozen, chief media officer at 360i.
The alternatives that advertisers and their agencies are finding range from redirecting dollars to other inventory controlled by a TV network to postponing deals until play resumes to asking a network to release an advertiser from a commitment. “There’s nothing that’s not on the table,” said one agency executive.
For the most part, ad buyers are looking to the TV networks to help them find alternative inventory rather than rushing to cancel campaigns, according to agency executives. Both sides recognize that the networks cannot plug their sports programming gaps with anything that would attract a comparably large and broad audience, “so it’s about how do we redirect and try to reach those audiences. That’s mostly been redirecting to digital video, OTT and advanced TV,” said Adam Simon, svp and executive director of strategy at UM’s IPG Media Lab.
There are cases in which individual advertisers have asked to be released from deals. These advertisers have typically been companies whose businesses have been hit by the coronavirus outbreak, such as travel companies, and the networks have agreed to the requests as a show of good faith in hope that those advertisers will return after the pandemic is contained. In some of these cases, the networks don’t actually lose money because some agencies have taken it upon themselves to find other clients willing to take on that inventory.
“We definitely don’t want to leave our partners high and dry. We actually haven’t had to cancel, so far, any of our agency deals,” said Brad Geving, vp of media at TV ad-buying firm Tatari.
How advertisers and TV networks grapple with the sports hiatus could serve as a test case for how they will deal with the broader issue facing the TV advertising industry. As viewership continues to shift to streaming, TV networks are forced to find ways to get their advertisers to follow suit without exchanging the proverbial linear dollars for digital pennies. At the same time, audiences’ attentions are fragmenting as their content choices expand, so networks need to cobble together audiences across their different inventory sources to satisfy audience guarantees for advertisers.
Redirecting dollars away from live sports to other inventory sources is not an equal exchange. Not only will TV networks struggle to meet the impression guarantees that games would deliver, but the prices for that inventory are not equivalent. Ad buyers and networks are still trying to sort out those reconciliations, with the added wrinkle that people staying at home amid the outbreak could lead to increased TV viewership and partially offset impression shortcomings.
“I hate to say it, but it is from one hour to the next I’m getting updates on how we’re handling it with one network group to the next. So it is an ever-changing situation,” said the unnamed agency executive.
The Disruptor: Why AT&T tapped Jason Kilar to make sense of WarnerMedia
Kilar's history of questioning the status quo may be AT&T’s motivation behind hiring Hulu’s founding CEO to oversee WarnerMedia.
With ad prices declining, creators increase their production volume
With brand deals on hold and ad prices in decline, individual video creators are upping their video output to increase viewership.
Member ExclusiveCheaper remote productions help media companies save money during the pandemic
Remote productions cost roughly half to one-third of the amount for a traditional shoot, according to producers.
SponsoredPublishers are experimenting with more engagement models
A growing number of publishers are using registration walls, paywalls and metered models to collect first-party user data and drive subscription revenue.
Member ExclusiveHow coronavirus will shape the future of TV
The pandemic-driven sports hiatus will accelerate audiences' and advertisers' shift to streaming, but production shutdowns may have the broadest impact.
Member ExclusiveChild’s play: The streaming wars have come for the children
To hang on to adult subscribers, streamers including CBS All Access and HBO Max are stocking up on kid- and family-friendly programming.