The Death of the Banner Revisited

The banner ad’s demise has been greatly exaggerated. Even though it’s responsible for a $15 billion industry in U.S. display advertising, the banner sometimes seems universally reviled. Nobody — not publishers, agencies or tech platforms — seems happy with Internet display advertising as it currently stands. Leaving aside the vast targeting industrial complex, there’s the existential question for banners: Would publishers use them now if they were starting from scratch? The answer is probably no, especially when you look at the birth of “native monetization” formats on social networks like Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, Foursquare and the rest. They’re all turning their backs on “traditional” online display advertising. James Gross, a cofounder of content-curation tool Percolate, sees this as spelling the eventual demise of the display ad — or at very least its radical transformation.

This new world with no special box is a big shift from a brand perspective and these platforms will all force companies to act more human and interesting in nature. Creating, liking, Tumbling, pinning and publishing alongside others in a way similar to how we all use these channels today. Of course, this is not a new thought, but the interesting twist I would put on it is brands, in theory, have the advertising money to buy an audience much bigger than we can afford as people, or even publishers, on these channels.

Read Gross’ full article on AdAge. Follow him on Twitter @james_gross.

 

https://digiday.com/?p=11565

More in Media

How creators are using generative AI in podcasts, videos and newsletters — and what advertisers think about it

Here’s a look at how some creators are leveraging generative AI to create video, audio and written content — and whether or not that’s a turn-off for advertisers.

Illustration of a performer balancing money weights on a tightrope, symbolizing how brand safety tools help marketers maintain performance and control.

Buzzfeed, News Corp and New York Times push back on tariff fears in earnings calls

Publishing execs pushed back on tariff and macroeconomic climate fears in Q1 2025 earnings calls, expressing confidence that their businesses would grow this year.

Digiday+ Research: Publishers’ subscription revenue is up this year, and they’ll focus on growing it even further

Subscriptions is one area where publishers are seeing more revenue, and, in turn, ramping up their plans to strengthen that part of their business in the coming months.