Digiday Publishing Summit: Prices rise Aug. 5
Hear from execs at The New York Times, Thomson Reuters, Trusted Media Brands and many others
There are dozens of demand-side platforms out there, but are they a huge improvement? Not so much, according to Nathan Woodman, COO of Adnetik, an independent trading desk.
“The main reason DSPs are not good at valuing the quality of inventory is that they over-rely on the algorithm to make effective decisions,” said Woodman. “For example, we know that below the fold inventory is twice as likely as above the fold inventory to receive last view based attribution. This means a cookie is dropped with a high likelihood that the ad is never seen.”
If a DSP simply lets a buying algorithm run free without restricting the space through quality control tools, said Woodman, then the algorithm will actually pay a premium to serve ads in placements which are not seen.
Another problem with DSPs according to Woodman is their often stand-alone use of third-party data, data which is available to every other buyer in the market.
“DSPs are good at leveraging third-party data,” said Woodman, but they lack the ability to find segments tailored to a specific advertiser. DSPs tend to attract bargain-hunters, not brand-sensitive advertisers, according to Woodman, and this discourages premium publishers from releasing high-quality inventory with transparency as they believe it causes CPMs to plunge.
The rise in private ad exchanges, according to Woodman, is a result of publishers’ discomfort with the DSP status quo and advertisers’ unhappiness with the lack of transparency throughout the buy process. Ad exchanges that offer transparency and utilize first and third-party data effectively along with brand protection controls will continue to pull major brands and a larger share of ad spend than DSPs. Woodman doesn’t imply that it is impossible for DSPs to offer the right mix of transparency, high-quality inventory and cost-management, but at present there is “no way” for brands relying on a DSP in its present incarnation to optimize competitive advantage.
An earlier version of this article said Adnetik is owned by Havas. It was spun out of the ad holding company and is now independent.
More in Media

Creators are ‘doubling’ their rates as they capitalize on brands’ growing interest
August 4, 2025
Seven influencer marketers tsaid that creators’ rates had risen noticeably across all platforms, although they provided a range of figures regarding the specific amount.

From immigration to AI, what companies need to know about Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill
August 4, 2025
The changes ahead are both immediate and far-reaching, touching everything from immigration compliance to workplace culture and AI governance.

What talent booker Joanna Jordan can teach about leading in media transformation
August 1, 2025
Whether it was Netflix transforming to content powerhouse or a Hollywood labor disputes fueling the creator economy, Jordan has found herself ahead of the curve.