Can a social network be too refined? John Borthwick thinks so.
Borthwick, the founder and CEO of the technology investment firm Betaworks, believes that Google+ was launched with too many features, before the company was able to see how people would actually use the product.
“I’ve been fairly bearish on Google+,’” Borthwick said on Thursday (Sept. 22) at the Digiday Social conference in New York. “I don’t think its working. I thought it was over-architected. Usually you start small and design the experience with your users.”
Borthwick drew a contrast between Google+ and Twitter, which saw many of its more popular features, like the retweet button, come from users.
Google+ for the time being, seems overly designed to keep users on Google’s pages, rather than send them out across the Web (a very un-Google philosophy). And the participation numbers don’t look good at the moment.
But Borthwick is willing to be patient with Google+. “They are a startup in a sense,” he said.
Trending in
Most Read
More in Media
Digiday+ Research: Dow Jones, Business Insider and other publishers on AI-driven search
February 11, 2026
This report explores how publishers are navigating search as AI reshapes how people access information and how publishers monetize content.
In Graphic Detail: AI licensing deals, protection measures aren’t slowing web scraping
February 11, 2026
AI bots are increasingly mining publisher content, with new data showing publishers are losing the traffic battle even as demand grows.
In Graphic Detail: The scale of the challenge facing publishers, politicians eager to damage Google’s adland dominance
February 9, 2026
Last year was a blowout ad revenue year for Google, despite challenges from several quarters.