Some publishers appear to be cooling on Facebook Instant Articles
Several media outlets, some of them early adopters to Facebook’s fast-loading Instant Article format, seem to be posting less and less there, according to a new analysis by NewsWhip and confirmed in independent reporting by Digiday.
NewsWhip looked at several publishers’ posts to Instant Articles during a five-day period (Sept. 16-20). It’s hard to draw generalizations from such a short timeframe, but it found that while some publishers including The Huffington Post, Mic and Washington Post are essentially all in on the format, other early adopters (BBC News, National Geographic and The Wall Street Journal) barely seem to be using Instant Articles at all recently. NBC News and Business Insider, “seem to have pulled back as well from creating Instant Articles.” Facebook hasn’t yet responded to requests for comment.
Instant Articles has been controversial since Facebook launched it a little over a year ago. The draw is that articles load much faster than the Facebook links that take readers back to most publishers’ own sites, and engagement on those articles is often much higher than it is on regular Facebook links. But because Instant Articles live on Facebook’s platform, publishers lose some ability to monetize their articles and get skimpy reader data.
Since Instant launched, Facebook has also been aggressively pushing video over text articles in the news feed, which gives publishers more incentive to respond by posting lots of video, which rewards them with more engagement than text articles do.
National Geographic, which was one of the nine publishers that launched Instant Articles, confirmed it has been posting fewer Instant Articles. The publisher is typically posting one to two per day, said Declan Moore, CEO of National Geographic Partners.
NBC News also admitted to having pulled back. The publisher said that when it first started using Instant Articles, it was posting “pretty much all” of its top content so it could see what worked best on the platform. NBC News has found that people are willing to click through to its site when there’s breaking news, so it’s posting less of those articles on Instant Articles while posting more feature-type content, a spokesperson there said.
The Boston Globe, which wasn’t part of the NewsWhip analysis, stopped posting to Instant Articles after a brief test. For two to three weeks, the Globe published all its articles as Instant Articles, said Matt Karolian, social media director for the Globe, and “We didn’t see a lift in engagement, at least not materially.”
Back in May, Business Insider was posting 10 percent of its Facebook links in the form of Instant Articles; of 100 articles it posted in the past day, just two of them were Instant Articles, which are identified by a lightning bolt in the upper-right corner. A spokesperson for BI said there’s been no top-down change in strategy but couldn’t rule out other changes by audience development.
Other publishers seem to be getting more analytical about how they’re using the format, which could account for some of the pullback. During the five-day period, according to NewsWhip, The New York Times published 22 articles to Instant, or 10 percent of the articles it posted on Facebook. They tended to be long-form think pieces or analysis, not breaking news, perhaps for their longer shelf lives.
The counting approach could account for some of the apparent decline. During the time period NewsWhip analyzed, The Atlantic had 10 percent of its Facebook links in the form of Instant Articles. That’s far below the 85 percent of links that the publisher has said in the past that it was posting to Instant. The Atlantic is still publishing all new articles in the format when possible, but the five-day period covered a weekend where it often resurfaces more archives and videos, which aren’t published as Instant, the publisher said.
How Forbes’ 30 Under 30 franchise has become a top selling point for the brand
The 30 Under 30 franchise has given Forbes another avenue to sell its advertising clients on cross-platform campaigns for top dollar.
‘Outside the four walls of a restaurant’: Why The Infatuation cooked up a marketplace model during the pandemic
The NYC-focused marketplace, which offers everything from private dinners to cooking classes, will be braided into the rest of the Infatuation's business next year.
‘I believe enough in this to try to do it myself’: CollegeHumor owner Sam Reich on the brand’s future potential
In January, IAC decided it was no longer willing to finance CollegeHumor and sold it to Sam Reich, who had joined the company in 2006 to build out original video.
SponsoredWhy ad buyers (and sellers) need to pay more attention to viewer attention
By Yan Liu, CEO, TVision Like the proverbial tree falling in the forest, we all recognize that oftentimes the TV is on, but no one is in the room to hear or see it. And yet some ad buyers continue to rely on a metric that fails to account for this. To mix metaphors, buyers […]
‘The experience is much more valuable’: How publishers are testing hybrid approaches to keep their events engaging
In order to reignite the spark of excitement that experiential is meant to offer, some publishers have begun testing the limits of hybrid events.
Care packages replace canapés as Coronavirus cancels media holiday party extravagances
With social distancing keeping coworkers apart in December, media companies and agencies have turned to care packages to replace the holiday party.