Why designers hate on the article progress bar
Publishers with progress bars on their article pages might be taking a step backward.
As sites push out more and more content of varying length, some are thinking up new ways to give readers a better idea of what they’re getting into. For some, such as Bloomberg and The Daily Beast, this thinking has led to their implementation of article progress bars, which let readers know in real time how much they’ve read — and how much farther they have to go.
The logic for the move is straightforward: By giving readers more information about how long a given article is, publishers put readers in the driver’s seat. But designers have their own opinions.
“It’s a neat feature, but it doesn’t make sense on blog posts or most digital content. Unless you use it for long-form stories, it just winds up being distracting,” said Kevin Kearney, CEO of Hard Candy Shell, adding that publishers should avoid using the feature across all of their articles. He said that Hard Candy Shell has “blacklisted” the feature and pushes back against clients who request it.
Designers say that the progress bar is similar to features such as the hamburger menu and infinite scroll, which publishers often adopt because they see them elsewhere, not because the features make sense within their strategy or for their audience.
Bloomberg, which added the progress bar as part of its January redesign, uses the feature for the majority of its articles, including its shorter news stories and longer features, on both desktop and mobile. It has also incorporated it into a March feature about a Seattle tunnel drill, which featured an animated drill that progresses as readers scroll down. At the Daily Beast, the feature is used to help readers keep track of their progress as they move down the site’s continuous scroll.
“The progress bar exists because we think that subtle hints that give users more context and control over how they experience our stories are a good thing,” said Bloomberg digital managing editor Michael Shane. “When I see it on our site or on others, I feel more empowered and have a better grasp over how much time I need to complete a story.”
The New Republic turned heads when it added the feature as part of its 2013 redesign, but it has since been scrapped. The New Republic declined request for comment on about why it dropped the feature. But Kearney, who helped design that iteration of The New Republic, said the move came as the site shifted its focus away from long stories to shorter ones.
Charming Robot CEO Dan Maccarone, who called the progress bar “gimmicky” and “distracting,” said that the progress bar is also a product of publishers overthinking the reading experience. A better solution, he said, is the Medium approach: Tell readers exactly how long it will take them to read articles.
“I like that idea of having my expectations set before I click. To me, that’s more valuable than showing me my progress as I’m going though the article,” he said.
‘A digital Madison Square Garden’: How Complex reimagined the sponsorship opportunities for ComplexLand
The online event, which will combine music, conversation, gaming and shopping in an online world, will have 60 sponsors.
‘People have had permission to experiment’: Pandemic expedites rethink on 9-to-5 work structures
Starting out as a short-term fix to weather the coronavirus storm, employers are seeing work hours outside the traditional 9-to-5 week as a new normal.
‘They wanted to unload it bad’: Why HuffPost made sense for BuzzFeed – and Verizon Media Group
BuzzFeed's acquisition of HuffPost will give it access to an older, more affluent cohort, potentially bolstering its news and commerce businesses.
SponsoredA buyer’s guide to new CTV terminology
by Austin Scott, Head of EMEA Video Market Development at Xandr There has been a seismic shift in the way audiences consume content. The average U.S. home owns 11 connected devices. More than 40 percent of consumers use connected TV (CTV) devices to stream content daily, and 77 percent of households are considered CTV households. […]
‘A start-up again’: New Quartz owner Zach Seward’s plan for longevity includes revenue innovation and reader support
Seward would not disclose current financials, but the upswing in ad revenue in third and fourth quarters has him optimistic about the company's position for 2021.
NBCUniversal and Volition Beauty sign multi-year deal to co-create products
The partnership leverages the fame and influence of people who exist somewhere between influencer and mainstream celebrity.