Compensation for long hours worked comes in many forms. Whether it’s cold hard cash or a cold hard metallic award, it’s all about getting recognition.
However, problems inevitably occur when those outcomes are skewed to meet unrealistic projections and coddling egos. Overly favorable revenue forecasts, stacking up points from clients at awards shows, and having journalists write to a set metric to obtain traffic goals point to deluded thinking.
As a response to the Art Directors Club annual awards show, Agency Exec X sought to expose the current agency digital identity crises by elaborating on the ways in which agencies will game awards shows to prove they can do it all to clients. In the opinion of Agency Exec X, “If everyone would stop pretending we would all be better off.”
The executive director of the ADC, Ignacio Oreamuno, wrote in agreement in his post, “The True Hope of Awards Shows,” that selfish acts aren’t furthering the greater good of the advertising industry.
“If we completely re-haul the award show system, which I am definitely going to do at ADC, we can convert award shows back into helpful, non-partisan resources that help our industry advance each year. I asked all of my judges this year to reflect on the following question when awarding any ADC Cubes: “What message are you sending the industry when you award this piece? What is the lesson behind this award-winning entry?”
Publishers are also guilty for placing unrealistic expectations on their staff in effort to boost the company appearance for clients. Digiday’s Josh Sternberg covered the effects of placing such incentives within a pay structure last week, emphasizing that quality might suffer as page views climb.
However, there are other options, says Jason Pontin, editor-in-chief and publisher at MIT’s Technology Review. Pontin suggests an alternative that would measure user interaction versus the number of clicks per piece.
There are a variety of different audience behaviors for which a publisher could reward writers, depending on the outcomes the editors wanted. One interesting possibility, for publications that wanted quality: low “bounce”. (Bounce is the tendency of a reader/user to leave a site: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bounce_rate.)
Tarik Sedky, president of MN&P, “Why TV Still Wins” touts that the TV industry is still throwing great parties this spring as a result of having an ad system that seems to be working. Alex Couch, an acquisition marketing manager at Practice Fusion, thinks the expectation that TV will continue to hold out against current digital trends is false.
As for the great parties; to me, those are evidence that upfront buying is still a crony game, not that it’s here to stay.
Perhaps more industries should take a cue from Oreamuno and revamp their practices for this pat-on-the-back syndrome.
Image via Shutterstock
‘Death by a thousand paper cuts’: Publishers fret over alternative ID overload hurting site performance
Publishers lack the data to know which IDs they can afford not to support and are worried a surplus of IDs can slow page-load speeds and lower sites' search rankings.
Member ExclusiveMedia Buying Briefing: Separating agency progress from posturing around carbon reduction and sustainability
Could it be that the media world is finally taking concrete steps toward decarbonization — or will many of the efforts underway become the butt of a joke (or worse, the focus of an upcoming John Oliver segment)?
How The Independent is getting brands on board to advertise against breaking news
Advertisers are skittish about breaking news, but The Independent's Blair Tapper is trying to humanize the programmatic funnel to keep them spending during a tumultuous news cycle.
Sponsored<strong>How marketers are responding to shoppers’ wants this holiday season</strong>
Matthew Tilley, executive director, marketing, Vericast With the holidays right around the corner, the economy may force some consumers to adjust their plans and stretch their dollars even further. While some shoppers may rein in their spending, others will still go all out despite a cloudy economic outlook. Given the current economic climate, consumers are […]
How A+E Networks cross-promotes podcasts to improve discovery
A+E promotes its podcasts to grow an audience by marketing the shows to its TV audience and finding outside partnerships.
Overheard at Dmexco 2022
Ad tech's jamboree in Germany is back IRL after two years with dissenting voices striking a note of caution.