5 hurdles facing the spread of programmatic advertising beyond digital

By the end of this year, two-thirds of digital display advertising will be bought programmatically, eMarketer estimates. But will other forms of media adopt the same principles of efficiency-based buying? TV, cinema and out of home are starting to catch up, but there are still a lot of challenges, as buyers and sellers at Advertising Week described.

Chief among them are:

Data headaches
Automation can’t happen without having data in the right format, and buyers and sellers are in the early stages of figuring that out. “Steps that need to take place are getting inventory and scripts and metadata into a digital format,” said Scott Stansfield, president of Centriply, an ad agency that’s focused on targeted TV. “What we’re finding a lot of times is people are combining data sets that weren’t meant for linear television, and you’re getting these Franken-data sets,” added Michael Strober, evp of client strategy and ad innovation at Turner Broadcasting. “They need to understand the perils of not using the right data.”

Keeping the personal touch
The rise of automated selling in digital advertising hasn’t been without angst. Media owners wonder how they’ll continue to differentiate themselves as machines take on a bigger role in the buying and selling process. That’s a tension that sellers in other media have to resolve, too. “There is a role for science and more efficiency, but there’s always a role for the art, including the personal selling,” said John Patilla, CEO of Screenvision, a cinema advertising company. “If everything’s a level playing field, how do you win?”

Buyer beware
Ad buyers used to buying on Nielsen guarantees need to get used to an entirely new and much more complex buying model when they buy based on audience, and not all know what audience attributes to go after, Strober said. “Now, it’s easy because everything’s modeled off household impressions,” he said. “When you start breaking it down into audience, it’s like three-dimensional chess.”

Seller comfort
At the same time, sellers have a ways to go in figuring out whether they should put their limited inventory in an automated market or sell the old fashioned way to maximize their yield. “I have to take into account demands on my own inventory,” Strober said. “We have demand coming in but we need to decide how to allocate it, and that’s really hard.”

Old ways die hard
The cost and efficiency benefits of programmatic buying are leading traditional media to rethink the way they sell, as Time Inc. did when it announced it would sell its print magazines programmatically. But that may require the media to make big operational changes. At Clear Channel Outdoor, CEO Scott Wells admitted his company has a long way to go when it comes to getting sales of its printed media to catch up to the demands of automated buying. “We get signs up in five days,” he said. “We’ve got to do a lot better than that.”


More in Media

Google’s 2024 cookie deprecation deadline is still on, says vp of global advertising Dan Taylor

Google’s vp of global ads is confident that cookies will be gone from Chrome by the end of next year, despite all the challenges currently facing the ad market.

Mythbuster: How the inconsistent definition of click-through rates affects publishers and their advertisers

Some email newsletter platforms’ click-through rates are actually click-to-open rates, which are measured against the number of emails opened rather than the emails sent. But buyers seem to prefer it that way.

Digiday+ Research: Events will be key for publishers’ revenues next year

Publishers’ events businesses picked up pretty significantly during the back half of this year — and they will focus on sustaining that lift into 2024, according to Digiday+ Research.