The entire premise of online marketing has been that, unlike other channels, it is fully accountable. The wealth of tracking data, theoretically, means marketers can know what’s working and what’s not. The problem is that this just isn’t true, according to Shiv Singh, global head of digital and marketing transformation at Visa.
“Digital is not that accountable,” he said on this week’s episode of the Digiday Podcast. “If I were to have a heart-to-heart conversation with my CFO or CEO, I’d be embarrassed by how blurry and foggy the entire digital media ecosystem is. If you think of the conversations we’ve been having in our industry about ad viewability, fraud, different platforms having their own networks, all of this creates more confusion, makes it much more difficult to know, when you spend a dollar, what you’re getting back in return.”
Below are lightly edited and condensed highlights from the conversation.
Shifting money to digital isn’t innovation.
For a few years now, one way for marketers have shown they’re innovative has been to bragging about how much of their marketing budgets had gone from analog channels to digital. But that’s meaningless, according to Singh.
“None of that matters. You have to be performance-driven, and you have to be able to look at all your channels and platforms on a level playing field,” he said. “The shifting to digital is a bit of a distraction. In 2016, every major marketer should have figured out by now what is the optimal mix that delivers the best results.”
“It’s hard to know the truth” in ad tech.
The shift to programmatic has created massive amounts of complexity in media. Along with that complexity has come a lack of transparency on several fronts, including what fees are assessed by whom and what channels work compared to others.
“We face a pretty fundamental challenge,” he said. “It’s very hard to look comparatively at a spend on Facebook, or a spend on Twitter, or a spend at a premium publisher and put those side-by-side with a programmatic buy. It’s so hard to look at everything on a level playing field.”
Brands are worried they’re being ripped off.
The lack of clarity in digital media has created a trust problem. Singh said often he feels like he’s buying a car from an unscrupulous salesperson.
“If I were to explain how transparent the ad ecosystem is to my CFO or CEO, he would think I’m a moron,” Sigh said. “Our industry does not have enough transparency. It’s hard to know, that dollar spent, where it goes. It’s very hard on a media plan to tell what exactly is the buy, how much of that buy is going to the consumer, what are the fees on the back end, and who exactly is getting that money.”
Facebook’s got a measurement issue.
Facebook’s ad business is booming. It doesn’t hurt that it has 1.6 billion users. But for brand building, Singh still sees issues that arise from Facebook’s proprietary approach.
“Whenever you have a walled garden you have unique metrics,” he said. “That creates more confusion.”
The Rundown: Meta to put new ads all over Facebook and Instagram, including on user profiles
Meta is launching new ad formats this quarter, which are hoping to capitalize off of readers' appetite for discovery.
4A’s Marla Kaplowitz on 3 ways agencies can navigate the uncertain economy
The industry trade group is helping many agency members prepare their business for broader economic changes, from how to retain talent to honing their financial acumen.
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: Marketers, agencies report it’s ‘the perfect storm’ as new business pitches slow
The second and third quarters of this year were slower than usual for pitches, according to agency execs, who said there's a sense of pullback across the board from marketers this year.
SponsoredWhy online search is foundational for a post-cookies environment
Derick Jaros, head of industry, commerce, Yext If there’s one definite thing about the past two years, it’s that consumer behavior changed significantly throughout the pandemic. From the shift to online-only life in early 2020 to the frantic Googling for new hours, policies, and stock updates in the first phase of reopening, consumers turned to […]
After Kim Kardashian’s SEC settlement, influencers working with brands could face more scrutiny – and fines
On Monday, the SEC announced it had reached a $1 million settlement with Kardashian over her 2021 post promoting the crypto asset EthereumMAX.
Productivity app Notion goes global with OOH efforts
As productivity app Notion expands its business, it is ramping up global OOH efforts to get in front of shoppers across the world.