Copyranter: Digital is destroying all creativity
Mark Duffy has written the copyranter blog for 10 years and is a freelancing copywriter with 20-plus years of experience. His hockey wrist shot is better than yours. Follow him on Twitter.
The popular opinion — especially among you Digiday readers — is that the computer, attached to the Internet, has been a creative boon for creative people. That’s horse-hockey. It has created Sameness. Lazy, lame, search and steal, click and grab, copy and paste, Sameness.
As my boss clearly laid out last week reporting on #TheDress phenomenon, digital “journalism” is more and more every day becoming viral (and non-viral) Sameness. “News” publishers that viciously, regularly mock BuzzFeed also regularly copy and paste their posts. One of the most vicious (and effective) attackers, Gawker Media, steals BuzzFeed posts so often it makes them look like a sad clown holding a bloody knife — in fact, that should be their new brand mascot.
But the Sameness doesn’t stop with journalism. Veteran fashion designers bemoan the lack of creativity displayed by today’s graduating students. Earlier this year, famed British designer Zandra Rhodes told Marketing Magazine that the digital world provides little inspiration.
“The new digital designs are more obvious, and they lack repeat ingenuity,” she said. “I think the computer and the digital revolution has damaged creativity and drawing in textiles. It is too easy to lift photographs. It is too easy to mirror images to create repeats. As a result, motifs today are merely repetitive.”
Rhodes does point out the one and only benefit that the “digital revolution” has brought to the creative process: speed. But speed kills creativity, too. Especially advertising creativity, the thing that has owned my mind for 25-plus years. Tech-savvy digital ad agencies have forced traditional shops to speed up. That part is, partially, a good thing. But a vast majority of these digital agencies are creatively bereft hacks, long on buzzwords, short on original concepts. And no, getting your client onto that Snapchat thingie is not a branding concept. But they are now at an equal consideration level for almost all new ad business, dragging down the overall creative product with them.
Clients are equally to blame because they’re the ones buying this shitty creative work. They’ve swallowed, not just the hook, line and sinker, but the whole metrics and “eyeballs” fishing boat. The Mad Men level (not the TV show) of ad craft has never been longer gone.
But back to the Sameness. Ad industry-famous Joe La Pompe, who has remained anonymously “masked to unmask the copycats” since 1999, can show you how the “digital revolution” has been a coup for lazy creatives. He obsessively documents all the instances of obvious, blatant idea theft in advertising. Click the link and take on an amazing tour of unoriginality. He is doing the gods’ (Bernbach, Ogilvy, et al.) work.
In the 1980s, pre-Internet, if an agency stole another agency’s idea, it was big news, covered top-of-page by AdAge and Adweek. Now? It hardly ever gets a mention in the trades — because it happens all the time. And it happens all the time because search engines are now very precise robbery tools. Beats having to work, and the client will probably never find out, shhh…
I am not going to start linking to ads, but think of all the dogs and cats selling beer and cars other non-pet things you’ve seen, all the talking animals, all the awkward white people rapping, all the stupid, fake, similar “shockvertising” videos made to “go viral,” all the patronizing bullshit “femvertising” (more on that soon), all the dad- and mom-vertising that look and feel more like demographic study videos than ads.
When the uncreative duh Oreo Super Bowl tweet is held up high as brilliant real-time marketing, it’s maybe time for me to go start a Christmas tree farm in Vermont.
Homepage image via Shutterstock
Member Exclusive‘Truly integrated’: As an unusual school year commences, agencies are aiming to help working parents more than ever before
Agencies, which have long had reputations as difficult work environments for working parents, are adapting to be more flexible for parents this year.
‘How much do we want to get screwed?’: Confessions of an agency exec on lack of payment due to coronavirus
In the latest edition of our Confessions series, we hear from one agency exec who says that the “times are tough” excuse for late client payments isn’t cutting it anymore.
‘Doubling down’: Inside the 49ers social and digital rush to replace lost in-stadium marketing dollars
Without the ability to deliver ads to the 70,000 fans who attend games in-person, the 49ers have had to pivot to focus on digital and social channels.
SponsoredB2B events were broken before the pandemic, their online reinvention is creating positive change
Kim Darling, executive producer, Inbound Farewell lanyards, business cards and branded pens — it’ll be some time before people get their hands on these souvenirs of in-person events again. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to transform the way people work, buy, sell, socialize and entertain themselves, the global events industry is facing its biggest-ever challenge. […]
Member Exclusive‘Can’t really be ignored’: Marketers and media buyers are finally taking the on-going TikTok saga seriously
Marketers and media buyers have said that as long as people are still on TikTok they’ll want to be there, especially as they try to diversify from Facebook and Google.
‘Clever about how we rest’: As uncertainties drag into fall, agencies are facing a burnt out and fearful workforce
Agency employees and executives say that a feeling of fatigue due to the on-going uncertainty and the need to be always on has set in.