Sorrell’s exit from WPP leaves a void in the fight against the duopoly
As head of WPP, Martin Sorrell had been one of the best known and outspoken critics of the tech giants, credited with first dubbing Google a “frenemy” as early as 10 years ago. His exit from WPP after an investigation into alleged misuse of company funds leaves a void not just at WPP, but in the ad and media industries as they try to curb the tech giants’ expansion into digital media.
Sorrell built WPP into the world’s biggest advertising holding company, but it’s now on its heels. The agency model has been squeezed by clients’ demands for more transparency in how their money is spent, clients’ contracting fees, competition from other industries trying to take a bite out of the agency business and cheaper alternatives for digital advertising services. Client spending with WPP is down, its share price has declined 30 percent, and hedge funds are betting against WPP and its ilk.
One of the factors driving the struggles of the holding companies is the shift to digital, which tech giants have capitalized on at the expense of traditional media and marketing companies. The tech giants are at a pivotal point now, though, with public opinion turning on them and rumblings of government regulation growing louder. Last week, Congress grilled Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg for two days on his business model after revelations that Facebook enabled Russian interference in the 2016 U.S. presidential election.
“Congress and the EU are seeing the bloom coming off the rose, and it’s unfortunate that Martin should be leaving at a time when he’s unable to take on Google and Facebook in a different way,” said Rob Norman, the recently retired longtime global chief digital officer of GroupM. “It’s pretty clear that the last five to seven years, the playing field has been tilting in one direction — not just for WPP, but media owners and advertisers in many ways.”
“How he played his cards was going to be super important,” said Jason Kint, CEO of Digital Content Next, a trade association for digital publishers and vocal critic of the duopoly. “We were just starting to see those cards get played.”
WPP’s calling attention to the duopoly had outsize impact, just as it did when its agency GroupM would demand transparency standards that exceeded the industry’s. Sorrell’s star power gave his words extra punch, and he used that voice to win over clients. It’s hard to imagine a less visible, less quotable replacement having the same impact.
David Chavern, president of the News Media Alliance, which represents 2,000 publishers including Dow Jones and The New York Times, recalled Sorrell speaking at one of the trade association’s conferences a couple of years ago.
“The audience was absolutely enthralled,” said Chavern, who has lobbied for an antitrust exemption for his members so they can bargain collectively with Facebook and Google. “You just had to ask one question, and the rest of the 45 minutes was his answer. He was the celebrity in this world, and there aren’t many of them. It has to be considered a loss for the debate about advertising and publishing.”
As Sorrell talked about the tech giants as frenemies, WPP also has become a big customer of Google and Facebook, spending $7 billion there in 2017. Google and Facebook ranked No. 1 and No. 3, respectively, for clients’ media spending, ramping up significantly over the past five years. WPP’s spending on traditional media was dwarfed by comparison. Google, Facebook, and increasingly, Amazon, have become must-buys for advertisers, so as WPP spends money with them, it helps solidify their market share at WPP’s own expense.
At the same time, Sorrell went around to industry conferences and talked to investors about the importance of preserving traditional media, which some could see as a contradiction.
“At the very least, his role and voice across the industry had outsize impact,” said Kint. “So we don’t know at this point what will fill that from the buy side. There probably was no company more in a position better to weaken the duopoly.”
‘Boomer spring break’: Alaska Airlines is creating its own hype house for boomer influencers
With boomers being many of the first people vaccinated in the United States, the ability to get back to travel is more prevalent for that audience. So too was the pent up demand, according to Natalie Bowman, director of marketing for Alaska Airlines.
‘An early red flag’: Mobile ad industry grapples with early uncertainties from Apple’s tracking crackdown
It’s been a week since iOS users started receiving notifications that they could turn off cross-app tracking and unsurprisingly it’s difficult to draw any meaningful conclusions so far.
‘Culture is our number one export’: How an Atlanta-based marketing collective is pushing for tangible diversity gains
After a year of calls for radical change in the name of George Floyd, a collective of Atlanta advertising professionals is calling on the industry to put its money where its mouth is.
SponsoredHow The Company Store is reimagining customer experiences for pandemic-era growth
Throughout the pandemic, some retail categories have been inherently successful. Home furnishings and décor are among them; with consumers spending so much more time at home, updates and renovations flourished. Criteo data from the first half of 2020 showed sales for items like outdoor furniture sets up 434% year over year, with other home items […]
‘Inflection point’: Microsoft’s GM of Global Advertising Business on privacy, ad business growth
Digiday caught up with Steve Sirich, to hear how the company is pitching advertisers today and how work-from-home has impacted the company’s ad business.
Facebook is ‘not a researchers-friendly space’ say academics encountering roadblocks to analyzing its 2020 election ad data
As governments aim to regulate social media to assuage problems with misinformation and election meddling, researchers are skeptical of restrictions in new political ad data from Facebook.