More scrutiny of YouTube stars’ promotion deals
YouTube stars have made a mint off cutting promotional deals with brands. Now, they’re getting more scrutiny over whether these promotional deals are properly disclosed.
The United Kingdom’s advertising watchdog, the Advertising Standards Authority, is pushing back against lackluster disclosures on branded YouTube content. The self-regulatory body issued a ruling on Wednesday that warns $65 billion snack giant Mondelez, which paid five popular U.K YouTubers to promote its Oreo brand. With 6.9 million subscribers across their channels, Thomas Ridgewell, Emma Blackery, PJ Ligouri, Phil Lester and Dan Howell made videos for Mondelez in which they participated in an “Oreo Lick Race.” Millions of viewers watched the YouTube stars furiously lick the cream off Oreos, but not all of them understood they were watching advertisements.
Each creator referred at some point to a relationship with Oreo, both in the videos and accompanying text descriptions. But statements like “thanks to Oreo for making this video possible” are not sufficient disclosures, according to the ASA, which was prompted to investigate the campaign by a BBC journalist. The videos have since been amended to include a clearer statement, “This is a paid for advertisement,” as a video annotation overlay and in the descriptions.
The ASA ruling, the first to mention YouTube, sets a new standard for the region. “The ads must not appear again in their current form,” reads the ruling. “We told Mondelez U.K. Ltd to ensure that future ads in this medium made their commercial intent clear prior to consumer engagement.”
That last part is key: The ASA is demanding labeling that communicates whether content is an ad before potential viewers click play.
“There is nothing wrong with vloggers entering into a commercial relationship, they just have to be up front with their viewers about that fact,” said Hannah Law, press and public affairs assistant for the ASA. “This means making a distinction between ads and editorial-based content so viewers can make an informed choice.”
An independent regulator, the ASA has the authority to apply a variety of sanctions to advertisers who don’t play by its rules. It can invoke mandatory pre-vetting for the most serious or persistent offenders, requiring advertisers to submit their marketing materials for review before publication for up to two years.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) also requires Web video makers to disclose endorsements, sponsorships and other payments from brands. It doesn’t have specific regulations governing YouTube, as the site falls under its 2009 Testimonials & Endorsement Report (and the 2013 “.com Disclosures” update), according to Mary Engle, the FTC’s associate director for advertising practices.
“The basics are that the disclosure has to be in words that the consumer can understand — it can’t just be a URL or a link, it has to be in a place where consumers will see it,” Engle told Gamasutra in October. “Certainly as a practical matter, the best thing would be to put it in the video itself, and for the person to say it.”
The ASA’s Mondelez ruling points to a potential regulatory headache for the burgeoning YouTube creator economy. Many creators have global followings, which attracts global brands like Mondelez. It also means that YouTube stars will need to comply with the most stringent global requirements. So even if the FTC isn’t taking aggressive action, the fact that the ASA (or European Union) is means the creators must comply — or risk possible sanctions.
Several multichannel networks, which negotiate advertising deals between top YouTube talent and major brands, declined to comment for this story. A representative for one MCN, which also works with Mondelez, said its branded campaigns are clearly labeled across all social platforms. But given the labeling of its recent branded series, which doesn’t appear on a brand channel or include a brand name in the title, the ASA would surely debate that claim.
There’s ample reason for advertisers to downplay the brand connection: Most obviously, it could limit audience appeal. In June, YouTube brand management software maker Octoly released a study examining the video game ecosystem on YouTube. It found that views for user-generated video content outnumbered branded content views 19-to-1 in that category, even after accounting for paid promotion.
But in general, disclosure is in everyone’s best interest, said eMarketer analyst Paul Verna. “As a general principle, people don’t like to be confused or misled,” he said. “It’s just not in the best interest of long-term brand health to do that just to get people to click on an ad.”
Cheat Sheet: Google extends cookie execution deadline until late 2023, will pause FLoC testing in July
Google will phase out third-party cookies in Chrome over a three-month period ending in late 2023 following testing of its Privacy Sandbox ad methods, under investigation by the UK's competition authority.
As ATT hits critical mass, media spending see-saw from iOS to Android continues
iOS versions (14.5.1, 14.6, and 14.7) that featured the App Tracking Transparency privacy safeguard are reaching critical mass.
‘The pandemic has proven it’s doable’: Inside Pepsico’s flexible-working model
Like many dads before the pandemic, PepsiCo's chief talent officer barely saw his kids in the week. Now, with its new flexible model he can be just as productive at work but spend valuable time with his family.
SponsoredNew data shows contextual targeting is driving brand safety and favorability
Paul Goldbaum, Chief Technology Officer, Seedtag In a very top-level approach, return on investment is among one of the top-ranking KPIs that brands prioritize when it comes to ad campaigns. However, in an online world filled with misinformation, fake news and unsafe content, brand image and favorability also need to be a top consideration ahead […]
The Job Juggle: Gen Z and millennial employees embrace the concept of ‘Polywork’
The professional workforce, particularly among millennials and Gen Z, increasingly is rejecting the concept of a full-time job and a single boss in favor of something that’s being dubbed “polywork,” or having multiple jobs at once.
Media Rating Council denies accreditation for Pinterest’s video ad measurements
The MRC denied accreditation for Pinterest's self-provided video metrics because the platform's counting method did not meet industry standard minimum requirements.