How Russian trolls can slip ads past Facebook
To Facebook’s dismay, Russia is trending. On the heels of a report that revealed Facebook overestimated its reach, the company admitted on Wednesday that a Russian “troll farm” spent $100,000 on ads on its platform between June 2015 and May 2017 to influence U.S. politics.
Both of these blunders are minor given the scope of Facebook’s ad business, but the Russian operation in particular is noteworthy as it illustrates the perils ad platforms face when they are engineered to have as many advertisers as possible.
The Russian operatives probably didn’t need to go through an ad agency and instead just used Facebook’s self-service ad buying tool, an ad buyer said, speaking anonymously. To purchase ads on Facebook, a prospective buyer with a small budget only needs a credit card. Since the campaigns were so small, instead of getting a Facebook rep assigned to them, the Russian operatives probably only had access to a general Facebook email address, the buyer said. Facebook declined to comment for this story.
Most ads submitted to the platform get approved within a few hours. The ease of setting up an account allows Facebook to attract ad dollars from not just big brands but also mom-and-pop shops, and the low barrier to entry in setting up campaigns is one of the reasons Facebook has been able to keep growing its ad business.
With Facebook’s self-service tools, a troll farm could quickly submit hundreds of different ad creatives that vary slightly from each other, said Brendan Gahan, founder of ad agency Epic Signal. By submitting a lot of similar ads, the trolls could A/B test which messages slip through Facebook’s detectors.
For example, Facebook’s advertising policy bars shocking imagery as well as discrimination against personal attributes such as race and sexual orientation. Pushing many different ads through the platform could help the trolls find the sweet spot where their ads are borderline sensational but not enough to get banned. Sending various ads through Facebook also increases the probability that a single piece of propaganda slips through the cracks.
To avoid detection, political operatives could also hide their identities by masking their IP addresses with virtual private networks, said independent marketing tech adviser Nate Elliott. Using VPNs could make it appear like the computers purchasing inventory to display divisive ads are scattered throughout various locations and not working together, when in reality, they could operate from the same building.
The $100,000 in question was spent by 470 accounts over a two-year period, according to Facebook. In other words, the amount of money each account spent was negligible for a company that made nearly $10 billion last quarter.
Facebook isn’t the only platform under heat for spreading misinformation. Twitter is slated to provide Congress an analysis of Russian activity on its platform.
“Under normal circumstances, Facebook’s ad quality team would never even know these ads existed,” Elliott said.
Why Facebook’s limits on teen targeting are all part of its algorithmic ad playbook
As Facebook puts new targeting restrictions on reaching teens, marketers say Facebook's ad targeting algorithm could do a better job of targeting ads to them anyway.
With the Metaverse hype cycle at full blast, experts take the long view
The newfound prominence of the Metaverse has led to heightened scrutiny, with some observers rolling their eyes at what they perceive to be the tech industry’s latest buzzword of the month.
As gaming expands, endemic and non-endemic creative agencies emphasize their strengths
Though gaming-endemic agencies have a head start, non-endemic creative agencies are looking to muscle their way into the space using their advantages as larger and more established firms.
SponsoredData-driven solutions: Charting a better way forward for brands and publishers
Travis Clinger, senior vp of addressability and ecosystem, LiveRamp Updates to mobile identifiers and browser data privacy policies have become an everyday part of life in the advertising industry. The browsers and device manufacturers have made privacy a competitive differentiator, as consumers have become increasingly concerned over how their data is being used. As an […]
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: Zenni’s vp of growth marketing on making the switch to ‘bite-sized’ planning windows due to Covid
To get a sense of how one brand marketer managed those shifts for a growing brand, Digiday caught up with direct-to-consumer eyewear brand Zenni’s vp of growth marketing, Courtney Fadjo Biro.
‘Change without story is a mandate, change with story is purpose’: Why marketing and comms execs are being tapped for chief-of-remote roles
Chief of remote roles are gaining in popularity, and it's marketers and communications execs that have the skills to fit the bill, experts believe.