Retailers to Twitter: Get it together.
At the Digiday Retail Summit, happening this week in Laguna Beach, California, retailers — big, small, online-only and brick-and-mortar — all expressed frustrations with Twitter as a social platform. Many echoed the view of Silicon Valley that Twitter simply hasn’t evolved quickly enough.
Haven Beauty, which sells beauty products, has used Twitter both for service and transactional communication, but also experimented with every facet of its paid product: promoted posts, follower acquisition plans, lookalikes and “buy nows.” And right now, the brand doesn’t see the returns.
“The efficiencies are at a level that just don’t justify it,” said Erin Dwyer, Haven’s svp of global e-commerce, social and digital marketing. “The resources and time it takes to create custom content for Twitter does not equate to the engagement and activity, so it feels like a left-behind platform.”
Twitter does have a lot of products for retailers. There are promoted tweets that can run during pre-purchase advertising sales or discounts; customer service plans for retailers to answer product questions; mobile app promotion cards that can encourage downloads. Periscope lets retailers do unboxing or unveiling for new products or store tours; while Twitter ads help with new customer acquisition.
While Dwyer said targeting on Twitter is good — one big complaint retailers have with Pinterest, for example, is that targeting is not deep enough — the challenge is that retailers can’t seem to figure out what the value is for a customer on Twitter. Comparatively, Instagram is inspirational and visual; Facebook is for friends.
“Twitter has that capability but hasn’t tapped into the psyche of consumers that gravitate to use it,” Dwyer said.
Another retailer, who could not speak on the record, told Digiday that there simply aren’t enough viable options for marketers to want to spend money with the platform.
“Twitter still feels relevant as an outlet of communication; it just doesn’t factor when contemplating and allocating social media dollars for a media plan,” said this retailing executive. “I couldn’t recite back to you off the top of my head what my options are to spend money with Twitter. The other platforms are good at presenting their offering.”
A third retailer, who handles digital media marketing for a clothing company, agreed with Dwyer: It’s a struggle to efficiently spend on the platform. And the launch of paid Instagram ads hasn’t helped: Budgets are moving there, this exec said, and Instagram ads are much more successful.
A short wish list from retailers:
- A way to figure out, for example, why a hashtag is trending, who started it and why — and a neatly delivered “summary” by Twitter with that information.
- A way to not miss tweets by certain people or brands just because you weren’t on Twitter when that person or brand tweeted something.
- A clearer sense of what Twitter’s for and why people should use it.
While a plethora of executives including head of media Katie Jacobs Stanton and product head Kevin Weil left the company earlier this week, Twitter appointed a new CMO, Leslie Berland on Tuesday. Her mandate will be to kick into high gear the Twitter brand, which CEO Jack Dorsey — already well liked by the agency buyer set — says is a priority for the company.
Brands stay silent on Tyre Nichols killing as marketers signal it as an industry backslide
Compared to the things that were said and acted upon during the murder of George Floyd and the protests that took place three years ago, many brands have been relatively quiet around Tyre Nichols.
Giant Spoon picks the Super Bowl to test ChatGPT’s marketing chops
As ChatGPT and AI rise in popularity, one marketing agency has chosen the Super Bowl to try out the technology's creative capabilities.
State Farm to skip out on a Super Bowl ad this year, going all in on TikTok instead
With a $7 million price tag, State Farm is skipping out on a traditional Super Bowl spot in favor of a TikTok campaign this year.
SponsoredAdvertising predictions that will shake up the media industry in 2023
Chris Kelly, CEO, Upwave Like many people, marketers and advertisers were ready to see 2022 come to a close. A year that started off promising was assailed by inflation, layoffs and the disastrous effects of RSV, the flu and additional COVID strains. Still, despite an uncertain outlook for 2023, there are plenty of reasons for […]
Marketing Briefing: Twitter, TikTok vie for ad dollars, offer incentives as they seek to own second screen for Super Bowl
While Twitter has traditionally been the platform that marketers turn to for real-time marketing efforts during the Super Bowl, the shift in leadership and advertiser exodus over the last year has left its place in this year’s Big Game a question: Will its importance continue?
Digiday+ Research: Agencies’ clients more likely to invest in CTV over traditional TV
More than two-thirds of agencies said clients spend at least a little on TV marketing, Digiday+ Research found. And they're more likely to spend on CTV than traditional TV.