Opinion: Native advertising as we know it isn’t sustainable
Antoine Boulin is president of media at the publishing company Purch
The overwhelming majority of digital publishers (90 percent) have adopted or are considering adding native advertising to their sites. It’s seen as an effective tool by brands and advertisers, garnering 4.1 times more views on average per session and improving purchase intent by 18 percent compared to banner ads. And with spend forecasted to grow 33 percent to $5.7 billion in 2016, it may seem like a very viable option for publishers.
Native is still in its infancy, though. While two-thirds of advertisers are increasing their native budgets, it still only accounts for less than 5 percent of the average total ad spend. And many publishers pursuing this business model have come up against its flaws. Scale and cost of execution is one. Consumer trust is another – when editorial-looking content is controlled by a brand there can be backlash, as seen with The Atlantic’s sponsored content from the Church of Scientology lauding its leader David Miscavige.
I’ll dive a bit further into some of the reason why native – as we know it – may not be a sustainable in the long term.
Native content lacks scalability and measurable performance
When talking about native advertising, it is important to first define what we mean. The definition of native varies widely across the industry, depending on whom you ask. For our purposes, we bucket “native” into these two categories:
Native ads match the look of the media brand’s site or the social media brand’s posts. Native content has been written by or in partnership with the publisher/media brand. Ad blockers are a mounting problem for native ads, while, for the moment, native or sponsored content is immune.
Above all, for native content to be efficient, the content has to be interesting for the reader. While native content is increasingly popular with publishers, it requires significant resources for marketers. While they would prefer to leave control of native content production to publishers, marketers at both at the brand and agency level need to weigh in and go through lengthy approval process, making the costs of the content production hard to scale and, more importantly, making the content less relevant to the user. This creates a vicious cycle, where readership declines, resulting in decreased performance for marketers.
Performance-based advertising continues to be the largest segment of digital advertising, accounting for 65 percent of all Internet ad revenue in the U.S. The content within a sponsored post, or advertorial-type piece, generally isn’t performance-driven, yet 55 percent of marketers look to ads for their ability to influence purchases. Ultimately, when budget comes into question from higher up the chain, spend is more easily slashed where performance isn’t clear – and reinvested into another solution where it is.
For native content to deliver this, the publisher must put forward an enormous amount of front-end efforts to produce high quality content that meet the marketer requests and drive traffic to it, and still, the direct link to ROI can remain murky.
Native 2.0: Is e-commerce the key?
Commerce is an area many publishers are beginning to play in. On one end of the spectrum, Style.com is relaunching from the digital home of Vogue to a pure e-commerce destination. YouTube is looking to get in on e-commerce, too, and is introducing the ability to shop for products directly from its videos. TripAdvisor and Houzz, on the other hand, blend commerce into their sites and, at times, build it (and ads) right into editorial content. Then we have the growth of buy buttons, like Pinterest’s and Twitter’s.
These commerce-rich environments are great success stories of how a blended environment – publishing and shopping – can work. And this approach has roots in native, philosophically and visually. They do what native attempts to: serve the advertiser/brand and offer a relevant, utilitarian purpose rather than annoying the reader – all while providing the publisher revenue it needs to pay for quality content and continue to support the “free Internet.”
By reconciling user service and marketing performance, native commerce may be the only true scalable business model for native.
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: ‘Not a hypothetical problem’: ANA CEO Bob Liodice on why there needs to be a unified effort to combat hate speech
This week, GARM and the ANA announced they are working with Pernod Ricard to scale that initiative working with brands and social platforms as well as small and medium-sized businesses.
‘The data strategies of these companies aren’t progressive enough’: 10 Confessions on the pivot to privacy
An inside view of how privacy changes are having big consequences throughout advertising.
Why companies are using virtual concerts to introduce their users to the metaverse
Music is a spectacle, but it’s also a deeply social experience, a pairing of traits that experts believe make virtual concerts a perfect fit for companies looking to showcase the metaverse to skeptical users.
SponsoredHow retailers can be ready for holiday shoppers this year
Suchi Sastri, managing director and partner, Boston Consulting Group As the holiday season approaches and the pandemic continues to evolve, retailers want to know what to expect. Will e-commerce continue to grow at the rate it did last year? How big of a role will in-store shopping play in holiday shopping? While it’s still early, […]
As non-endemic brands eye the gaming space, a lack of industry standards is delaying their arrival
The caution with which some brands still approach the gaming industry -- and the need for better industry standards to help brands feel more informed -- were recurring themes at last week’s Digiday Gaming Advertising Forum.
Cheat Sheet: How Apple’s ATT is giving it more influence over ad dollars
The signs that Apple is building an ads business is there — here is what we actually know.