Opinion: If #LoveWins, why are brands silent on #BlackLivesMatter?

Alysha Light is founder and managing director of Flight PR.

When the Supreme Court granted marriage equality last week, the Internet filled with rainbows and brands rushed to join the #LoveWins campaign for what was likely the most celebratory Gay Pride weekend in history, and for good reason.

Social media platforms didn’t waste a second. Twitter added a rainbow-striped heart to the hashtag #LoveWins while Facebook created a rainbow-hued profile maker. Google displayed a special graphic for searches on “marriage equality,” and brands draped their logos with rainbow flags in proud displays of solidarity with the movement.

Meanwhile, in Charleston, South Carolina, an equally historic moment was playing out with fewer calls to action from corporate America.

I watched in awe as the President of the United States led thousands of mourners, and an audience of millions, in singing “Amazing Grace” — practically a Negro spiritual — while delivering the eulogy for murdered state senator Rev. Clementa Pinckney, who was gunned down alongside eight of his congregants by a white supremacist.

In his eloquent tribute, President Obama talked about the roots of lingering racism in America and why faith, and the church, is so integral to the lives of many African Americans.

The poignant scene, as well as the gruesome massacre that preceded it, took place in the very same state where just a couple months earlier a white police officer was filmed shooting and killing an unarmed black man in the back as he ran away following a traffic stop.

Charleston. Ferguson. Baltimore. Staten Island. Chicago. All across America, countless black lives have been lost, sparking the #BlackLivesMatter movement to broaden conversations around “the ways in which black people are intentionally left powerless at the hands of the state,” according to the website.

Screen Shot 2015-07-01 at 11.40.36 AM
Until the historic Supreme Court ruling on gay marriage this month, the hashtag #BlackLivesMatter was more frequently used than #LoveWins

So why aren’t brands as willing to support #BlackLivesMatter in the same way they were with #LoveWins?

Companies such as Walmart and Target did take some action by vowing to stop selling Confederate flag merchandise. And in another reaction to public bigotry, NBCUniversal recently took its own stand by firing Donald Trump after he made racist remarks about Mexican immigrants.

While these actions were lauded by the press and across social media, they remain isolated examples unaffiliated with a larger movement. As Starbucks discovered earlier this year, socially conscious campaigns can be tricky waters to navigate, especially when they concern race. The coffee chain was ridiculed by media outlets for attempting to spark a dialogue on race relations with its “Race Together” initiative.

As a communications professional, I know firsthand the impact brands have in amplifying social change, so I can’t help but wonder why there hasn’t been more vocal support of the black community in light of these times.

It seems I’m not alone.

Dr. Janée N. Burkhalter, associate professor of marketing at Saint Joseph’s University’s Haub School of Business, put it in perspective this way: African Americans have a branding problem.

“One reason marketers might be willing to risk an association with #LoveWins rather than #BlackLivesMatter is the simple fact that people like to talk about love. It’s less scary than talking about death or what it’s like to walk around and be afraid that your life is potentially at risk.”

“There’s been an erasure of black achievements and contributions to American culture beyond entertainment,” Burkhalter continued. “People don’t know that African Americans are doctors, PhDs, scientists, inventors and engineers. If they don’t know that we help, or perceive us to make no contributions to society, then why should we matter?”

The racist backlash that arose on YouTube following Cheerios’ “Just Checking” ad, which featured a mixed-race family, is representative of how people in America still struggle with the topic of race and the place that African Americans have in society.

Following #LoveWins, Darnell Moore, senior editor of Mic, wrote: “I refuse to take pride in a ‘movement’ singularly invested in gay liberation while black and brown folk continue to die at the hands of the state and white vigilantes. …[Not] while white LGBTQ people refuse to confront the anti-black racism within their liberal communities. Not while marriage equality work can amass more money than programming for trans women of color and LGBTQ youth. Not while undocumented LGBTQ people continue to be detained and abused by the state. Not while I must daily argue for the mattering of black lives.”

At its core, #LoveWins celebrates the triumph of acceptance over intolerance. It’s a beautiful demonstration of our potential for progress when we collectively stand against any form of divisiveness. Similarly, #BlackLivesMatter deserves our support because we need to change how we talk about race in this country. Lives are depending on it.

If there were ever a time for brands to join that discussion, it’s now.

Image courtesy of a katz / Shutterstock.com


More in Marketing

CMO Strategies: A guide to display ads — benefits, obstacles and trends

The third installment of Digiday’s 2024 CMO Strategies series examines current investment in display advertising, as well as the business strategies and challenges associated with this marketing channel.

‘It’s in Google’s best interest’: Sources urge more formal Privacy Sandbox legal terms

Some even ponder the benefits of regulating web browsers, just like a public utility.

Why angel investor Matthew Ball still believes in the metaverse

Matthew Ball’s 2022 book “The Metaverse: And How It Will Revolutionize Everything” was a national bestseller in the U.S. and U.K. On July 23, he plans to publish the second edition of the book.