James Gross is the co-founder of Percolate, a platform building the system of record for marketing.
Marketing — and the half-trillion ad budget underlying it — continues to grow at an impressive rate. At the same time, there have never been so many agency of record (AOR) relationships up for review, with agency tenure down a staggering 65 percent since 1984. In the past six months alone, global advertising leaders like P&G, Unilever, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, Kraft, L’Oreal and Visa have all publicly said they’re implementing new approaches to get the best creative work while keeping up with the pace and complexity of modern media.
Fundamentally, these marketers’ objective hasn’t changed. The goal is to win brand attention and sell more product. The same can be said for creativity: The most creative advertising exposes human truths that inspire customers and culture, and there’s more demand for this type of creativity than ever before. But beyond primary definitions, almost everything about how creativity is developed and disseminated is changing profoundly.
So the choice is up to us. We can either let creativity get watered down by waves of uninformative data, or create systems where technology guides creative expression to new heights. Ideally allowing client-agency relationships to last longer and, more importantly, allowing creativity to hold its rightful place as the most important discipline inside the marketing organization.
What’s changed, and what does the path forward look like?
Marketers love the idea of technology, probably a little too much. It quickly becomes a lazy obsession, one with hopes that data will solve everything, or new magical ad tech will automate award-winning campaigns so we can all vacation from Cannes Lions to Labor Day. This obsession is particularly well chronicled in Paul Ford’s recent piece in Bloomberg “What is Code?” Some marketers think they can just outsource technology and creativity to third parties who have all the answers. “What is Code?” was written for anyone who naively thinks that is even remotely possible.
There is also a counter-movement that creatives will get along just fine without technology, like the view shared by Mark Duffy in his Digiday piece, Copyranter: Between ad tech and creativity, an all-out war.
The challenge with Mark’s argument is it takes the easy way out by picking a side, rather than looking to bring two worlds together as they are meant to be (and clearly how they operate in real life). Of course creativity is messy and requires human input. But to talk about creativity in marketing as art that happens on a whim doesn’t respect the amazing systems that creatives put in place to do their job. At the end of the day, creativity is underpinned by science and systems. We know what advertising works not out of random chance but rather by building briefs, consuming culture, running tests, observing the response, and learning from it to perform the next creative cycle — that’s how you make money, not art.
As important as it is to look at creative truths, it’s just as important to consider a global truth. More than ever before, our world is changing in ways that will allow more people to purchase the products that are advertised to them. The world is getting richer as we transition to a global middle class that will grow from 1.8 billion to 5 billion in the next 15 years. The world is becoming more interconnected as the number of internet users doubles from 3 billion to 6 billion in next 10 years. And the world increasingly runs on software, whether that’s in the form of media (Facebook), real estate (AirBnB), transportation (Uber), transactions (Stripe, mobile payments, bitcoin) or anything else. Marketing is entering a golden age, but it won’t happen unless we rethink the systems and creative processes we need to get there.
Throughout human history, from musical instruments and printing presses to Spotify and Instant Articles, technology has always helped creativity move faster, reach farther, and speak louder. This is just as true in marketing provided we take the right path forward. Let software handle repetitive tasks and the challenge of reaching people all over the world, so the creatives can speak to them about the truths they can’t ignore.
Why online lit platform Wattpad is keying its organic digital strategy on TikTok videos
Even as brands are shelling out more dollars for social media ads, online literature platform Wattpad is holding onto its ad dollars, opting for an organic social strategy.
‘A lot of waiting, watching and partying while Rome burns’: Confessions of an ad tech exec on the third-party cookie delay
In the latest edition of our Confessions series, in which we trade anonymity for candor, we hear from a senior exec at an ad tech company about what that limbo is like.
WTF is piggybacking?
Piggybacking is how an ad tech firm can drop a third-party cookie on a website's visitors via another ad tech firm that the website has granted access, as covered in this explainer video skit.
SponsoredHow marketers are tailoring data-driven creative to engage audiences on CTV
Gabriela Maestre, vice president of creative solutions, Tremor International As the end of the year approaches and marketing teams look to finalize their 2023 budgets, many are wondering how to ensure their ads are set up for success in the months ahead, appealing to unique audiences whose media consumption habits continue to evolve. Advances in […]
Fireball taps into streaming, Instagram to reach Gen Z of drinking age
To drive reach and awareness with Gen Z, spirits brand Fireball last month increased its digital video output on Instagram and streaming sites like ESPN, Peacock and Hulu with 15-20 second ads. It is the cinnamon whiskey’s first creative campaign to market to Gen Z, as many are now of legal drinking age. (The demographic […]
Why regulators are still at odds over ad tech data privacy standards
The problem with attempts to bring order to online advertising’s data industrial complex is how loosely written the rules are.