Notes from an ‘Old’: Ageism in the digital age

Mark Duffy has written the Copyranter blog for 11 years and is a freelancing copywriter with 25-plus years of experience. His hockey wrist shot is better than yours. 

I first found out I was an “Old” (as opposed to just old) in 2012 when I started working for BuzzFeed as an “ad critic.” At 52, I was by far BuzzFeed’s oldest employee. The under-30 editors there used “The Olds” or “Olds” internally (sometimes even in posts) as shorthand for anybody above the age of their demographic target, people who just didn’t “get” it.

I also found out that the term was used by millennials nationwide, not just at bleeding edge New York City social media websites. Before millennials came along, though, “The Olds” was (and still is) a group of old American whiskeys and bourbons (Old Grand-Dad, etc.).

I like that copy as a tagline for us new “Olds.”

Being called old isn’t pleasant, but to a 25 year-old, I am a geezer, no argument. But being called an Old is completely different: It then becomes a discriminatory word, an insulting word, a belittling word. This development has surprised me since it originated from a very savvy generation that has made strong strides against racism and especially sexism in the media.

I have neither a lawn nor a gun. And I’ve never ever held a conversation with a chair. But I am an old straight white male, the cause of every millennial’s every problem, seemingly, according to the internet.

But ageism? They seem to relish it. And this is directly related to the fact that millennials were the first “Digital Natives.” They think that us Olds don’t “get” computers and the internet as smartly as they do, and we never will. And they’re mostly right, aren’t they?

But given this starting point, it makes it really hard not to dislike them right back.

Last summer, Agency Spy, an Adweek-owned website with an inside eye on the daily lives of ad folk, asked their audience if agencies discriminated against people over 50. The response was a very loud YES.

The complaints were pretty consistent: Not only wasn’t experience valued anymore, neither was wisdom — the kind of wisdom one can only get by living, not Google searching.

The informal survey also found it was especially tough for 50+ females. This dynamic was touched on at a 2014 3% Conference session titled “Ageism: Advertising’s (Even) Uglier Secret.”

Today, if you’re over 50, especially if you’re a creative, you better already be in an executive position, or you better start thinking about changing vocations. Your experience is not only meaningless to headhunters, agency talent searchers and executive creative directors. It is a detriment because it isn’t the right experience; it’s “traditional” experience. You’re also probably too expensive.

Maybe if, from now on, I wore this t-shirt to every interview, the millenns would bae me.

It also doesn’t matter (much) that you’re more talented at copywriting, art direction, designing and “ideating” than the 25-year-old creatives. Agency execs can pay them doodly-squat, work them like pack mules, revise and drastically alter their work gleefully, and never have to hear any grumbling.

The result of all this is: The industry’s product (you know, the ads) sucks more than it ever has. So what? Yes, so what. Most brands don’t know the difference between mediocre and good work. Agencies just have to keep the brand people happy with a constant flow of ultimately useless social media metrics and, concurrently, pray hard every day that sales don’t fall. You want long-term thinking, creatively speaking? You’re funny! Yeah-no, sorry, not gonna happen.

I’m a pretty lucky 50+er. During my 18 months at BuzzFeed, I got a crash course in digital and social media. I can talk the talk, at least (I’ve fooled Digiday).

Now please excuse me as I take my daily trip around the web in search of great deals on Depends, Metamucil and gout treatments.

More in Marketing

Q1 ad rundown: there’s cautious optimism amid impending changes

The outlook for the rest of the year is a tale of two realities.

WTF is the American Privacy Rights Act

Who knows if or when it’ll actually happen, but the proposed American Privacy Rights Act (APRA) is as close as the U.S. has ever come to a federal law that manages to straddle the line between politics and policy.

Here’s how some esports orgs are positioning themselves to withstand esports winter

Here’s a look into how four leading esports orgs are positioning themselves for long-term stability and sustainability, independent of the whims of brand marketers.