The AdChoices program was billed as a way for the digital media industry to be more transparent with users about how their data are used online. But more than two years after its introduction, the icon is still omitted from many display ad impressions around the Web and misused in others, potentially confusing users and calling into question its efficacy altogether.
When it was formally unveiled by the Digital Advertising Alliance in October of 2010, the icon was designed to stave off formal legislation and regulatory scrutiny of online practices like behavioral targeting. As long as users are informed exactly why ads are being served to them and given the chance to opt out, then everything would be hunky-dory, the trade body said.
But the inconsistency with which the icon is currently being implemented risks undermining the effort altogether. It could easily confuse users as to what it actually represents. To start, it appears inconsistently based on which vendors and technology providers are involved with the serving of specific impressions. A user that visits an advertiser’s site will often be retargeted with ads across multiple publisher sites they visit afterwards, for example. The problem is even though the creative remains the same, some of those data-targeted impressions will include the icon and an explanation of the way they were targeted, and some will not.
The examples in the images below illustrate the point. The first shows two retargeted ads for LifeLock on MailOnline.com, neither of which include the AdChoices icon. The second shows two more retargeted ads on the same publisher site, one that includes the icon and one that doesn’t. The third shows a retargeted LifeLock impression on another publisher site, this time including the icon. Its inclusion is completely inconsistent.
On the other side of the coin, some advertisers and publishers attempt to cover themselves by including the icon in all the ads they serve, even if they’re not actually targeted using data. This, again, is misleading. Some ads claim they’ve been targeted based on users’ browsing histories when they haven’t.
Meanwhile some of the world’s biggest ad sellers an most prominent online brands don’t use the icon. Facebook — the world’s largest online display ad publisher — doesn’t yet use the icon at all, despite the fact advertisers can now employ extremely granular targeting tactics through its FBX ad exchange product. It announced plans to do so in February, but the icon itself isn’t appearing on ads yet.
This type of initiative takes time to get off the ground, of course. It’s impossible to expect every advertiser, publisher and ad tech company to adopt it overnight. But as the program and the AdChoices icon nears its third birthday, the current inconsistency around its implementation runs the risk of confusing consumers as opposed to educating them. The icon is now commonplace in data-driven ads, but it’s not ubiquitous, and that’s an issue.
There’s money to be made too, of course. Multiple tech vendors including TRUSTe, Evidon and DoubleVerify will help advertisers, agencies and publishers include the icon on their ads but for a fee. Some agency staffers argue the icon serves their interests more than it does those of the user, especially if it’s being implemented inconsistently or incorrectly anyway.
If the program is truly in the best interests of users, therefore, its implementation needs to be accurate and part of every data-informed impression. It’s the type of effort the entire industry needs to either buy into or just not bother with at all.
Image via Shutterstock
How gamers’ engagement with short-form video is changing
To better understand how modern gamers are engaging with short-form video, Digiday teamed up with Gamesight to pull key points from an exclusive report on gamers’ shifting video consumption preferences.
Inside SAG-AFTRA’s new deal with video platform Cameo
SAG-AFTRA and Cameo, the celebrity platform that connects talent and fans, have announced a new agreement that allows members to cover brand deals through Cameo for Business (C4B). Brands will be able to access more fan-favorite professional talent through SAG-AFTRA's health and pension plans.
Digiday+ Research: Extreme pessimism about the end of the cookie levels off among agencies
Agencies are still feeling out who they think the winners and losers will be as the end of the third-party cookie draws near, but they're doing so with notably less pessimism than they have in the past.
SponsoredHow agencies’ relationships with RMNs are continuing to evolve in 2023
This article is also available in Spanish. Please use the toggle above the headline to switch languages. Visit digiday.com/es to read more content in Spanish. Sponsored by Best Buy Ads As retail media networks proliferate, agencies are increasingly identifying RMNs as valuable opportunities for their brand clients as they seek quality audience data, meaningful reporting […]
Jose Cuervo Tequila celebrates UFC’s 30th anniversary with Kevin Holland, Stephen “Wonderboy” Thompson ads
Mexico-based Jose Cuervo, is the first tequila brand to be a direct advertiser of the UFC with spots featuring UFC fighters Kevin Holland, a Cuervo ambassador, and Stephen "Wonderboy" Thompson.
Benjamin Moore is using OOH near big-box retailers to say their paint isn’t there, encouraging people shop local
The 140-year-old paint brand wants to make sure people know that it is only available at local retailers.