Influencers weigh in on YouTube’s ‘censorship’ controversy
With a change in YouTube’s content moderation system, a tussle has broken out between the platform and a faction of its creators.
Controversy erupted last Wednesday, when YouTube creator Philip DeFranco — with 4.5 million subscribers on his channel — uploaded a video titled “YouTube Is Shutting Down My Channel and I’m Not Sure What To Do” in which he claimed flagged about 40 of his videos, citing some of his language and the topics he covers are “not advertiser friendly.” He went on to describe the system as “censorship with a different name.”
YouTube responded that it had not updated any policies regarding which videos are ad-ready and which are not. It has merely changed the communication around it, sending creators a notice when they mark a video as unfriendly for advertisers. The platform also instituted a new appeals process. Still, the hashtag #YouTubeIsOver was trending on Twitter last week.
Digiday caught up with some members of the influencer community for their reactions on the controversy:
Claudia Oshry: Instagram, YouTube and Snapchat
“I don’t think this is ‘censorship.’ You technically still can do and say whatever you want, you just can’t make money off of it now. I understand some brand’s concerns when it comes to vulgar content and not wanting to align themselves with those values. It’s an interesting dichotomy because the Internet is a safe space to do and say whatever you want, but when you monetize you become a representative for that brand. You have to respect their wants and needs.”
Jessica Franklin: Instagram and YouTube
“I understand the reasoning behind YouTube wanting to crack down on content and make sure everything is advertiser-friendly. However, I think the move comes at the expense of the users. I haven’t had anything flagged yet, but moving forward I feel like I’ll second-guess some of the content I’m putting out. These videos take a lot of time and effort to create and to have them taken down would be a big disappointment to me and my fans. I think the process should be closely monitored by the YouTube team to ensure there are real concerns before flagging a video and risk damaging the relationship with an influencer.”
Evan Garber: Snapchat
“A lot of videos, whether from user-generated or others like music videos and movie trailers, contain sensitive or inappropriate content. So if they are going to have these rules, they need to be equal for everyone. There should be no caveat to these rules, in that videos containing inappropriate content may still be eligible for monetization depending on the context. Whether it is a creator or anyone else, the same rules should apply. Everybody needs to be treated on an even playing field.”
Deepica Mutyala: YouTube
“I cover beauty, but if I were to talk about politics, which I am passionate about, I probably would be hesitant. The whole idea of the platform is to speak freely and be who you are. From that regard, it is weird, because does it mean that they are they going to continue to regulate things even more from this point? Having said that, I used to be on the brand side, so I also understand that as advertisers you want to make sure your that brand is being reflected in a certain way. But it seems to be against the spirit of YouTube.”
Jackie Oshry: Instagram and Snapchat
“Calling this ‘censorship’ is extremely dramatic. Censorship is a strong word to throw around and in this situation, I don’t think that’s what’s happening. YouTube isn’t censoring people from saying what they want to say. They’re just not going to pay you to say it anymore. While their motives for this are questionable, they are well within their rights to do so and creators have known this all along. At the end of the day, this comes down to the advertisers and they are not obligated to spend money on creators that they don’t want to align themselves with.
‘Doubling down’: Inside the 49ers social and digital rush to replace lost in-stadium marketing dollars
Without the ability to deliver ads to the 70,000 fans who attend games in-person, the 49ers have had to pivot to focus on digital and social channels.
Member Exclusive‘Can’t really be ignored’: Marketers and media buyers are finally taking the on-going TikTok saga seriously
Marketers and media buyers have said that as long as people are still on TikTok they’ll want to be there, especially as they try to diversify from Facebook and Google.
‘Clever about how we rest’: As uncertainties drag into fall, agencies are facing a burnt out and fearful workforce
Agency employees and executives say that a feeling of fatigue due to the on-going uncertainty and the need to be always on has set in.
SponsoredB2B events were broken before the pandemic, their online reinvention is creating positive change
Kim Darling, executive producer, Inbound Farewell lanyards, business cards and branded pens — it’ll be some time before people get their hands on these souvenirs of in-person events again. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to transform the way people work, buy, sell, socialize and entertain themselves, the global events industry is facing its biggest-ever challenge. […]
‘A credible voice’: Why Honda is doubling down on esports
Honda has struck deals with Riot Games, pro esports team Team Liquid and Twitch as it looks to maintain its appeal among first-time car buyers.
Member Exclusive‘2020 has been the year of contingency plans’: The new norms of marketing
Six months into a paradigm shift in marketing due to on-going crises, marketing leaders say that many of the coping changes put in place are here to stay.