Digiday+ Research: Independent agencies have little confidence in many digital advertising channels
Wanamaker’s dilemma is alive and well in digital advertising.
As brands and agencies continue to figure out how a raft of privacy-related changes will affect their ability to target and measure ads, they are being forced to reconsider channels that many had shaky confidence in, to begin with, according to new Digiday+ research.
In the third quarter of 2021, Digiday polled agencies and brand professionals about several different topics, including which widely used advertising channels drive marketing success, with the focus principally on digital platforms.
Digiday broke out the results among 70 respondents who work at independent agencies, defined as those not owned by holding companies.
The data quantifies something that has been widely understood in digital media for a while: That Facebook and Google dominate the digital ads space.
62% of respondents said Google accounts for at least a “large portion” of the ad spending they do for clients, with about a third of that total saying Google accounted for a “very large” portion; another 14% of respondents said the same (at least “large”) about YouTube. Similarly, 50% of respondents said Facebook accounted for at least a “large portion” of client ad spending, and another 46% said the same about Instagram.
Yet the defining feature among the platforms was just how few respondents were confident that any given channel drove results. Digiday asked survey respondents to rate their confidence in a list of channels using a five-point scale, ranging from “Not at all confident” to “Extremely confident.”
Google easily led the pack in this regard, with 68% of respondents that spent on Google saying that they were either “confident” or “extremely confident” it drove marking success. Instagram and Facebook followed, with 57% and 53% respectively.
Amazon is also in the mix, despite the fact that close to half of the survey’s respondents said they do not spend client budgets on Amazon. In fact, a higher percentage of respondents said they were “confident” in Amazon — 43% — than any other option listed. Notably, smaller percentages said they were “very confident” in Amazon which may reflect why Amazon comprised a “large” portion of ad spending for a relatively small share of respondents.
Every other option shown to respondents scored lower than 50%.
Indeed, one of the most striking features of the survey is just how many respondents said they were not at all confident in the channels they were advertising in. For a number of channels, including TikTok, television and publisher display ads, the percentage of respondents using a given channel that said they were “not at all confident” a channel was driving marketing success was as big or bigger than the percentage that said they were “extremely confident” it was driving success.
-
In-game advertising experts question Microsoft and Sony’s gaming advertising plans
The importance of free-to-play titles is one reason why some in-game advertising experts are skeptical about the tech giants’ ability to succeed in their chosen business.
-
‘A lot of these brands need a reality check’: Confessions of a PR agency founder on agency ‘jumpers’ and tense client-agency relationships
Confessions of a PR agency founder on agency 'jumpers' and tense client-agency relationships.
-
The vast majority of marketers are unhappy with their Customer Data Platforms, but then again, not many are sure what they really are
Marketers are confused by tech vendors', well, marketing as the requirement for complexity grows
-
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
-
How the layoffs at Upcomer show the challenges of public ownership in esports media
Enthusiast’s lack of a seemingly cohesive strategy for Upcomer is a reflection of the broader challenges it faces as a gaming and esports holding company that is, at the moment, one of the few publicly traded firms in the industry.
-
‘A lot of investment and commitment’: Manchester City ramps up esports efforts
Early forays from football teams into esports were conservative to say the least, opting to stay close to football and focus on competitive events for the Fifa football series.