You know that queasy feeling you get when you look at a yogurt in the back of the fridge with an expiration that pre-dates the previous World Cup? That’s precisely the feeling many consumers are feeling right now for Chobani, one of the leading yogurt brands.

After experiencing their first ever recall last year, the brand, which is normally quite clever in its social media approach, has hit another stumbling point. A new campaign centered around the hashtag #howmatters and has been met with a backlash the company ought to have seen coming. It wasn’t just that they built a social media campaign around the hashtag; it was that they built a nonsensical social media campaign around the hashtag. Lift up an aluminum lid of their yogurt and you’ll find the phrase: “Nature got us to 100 calories, not scientists. #howmatters.”

John Coupland, Professor of Food Science at Penn State was one of the first to chime in.

Drawing the ire of the scientific community is one thing, and might not result in much of an impact. However, showing your core customer base that you not only take inane directives blindly from your marketing department — but you have no idea how base and ignorant they sound — is another.

I asked some prominent social media moms (a genuinely large demographic that influences the buying decisions of many) if this marketing blunder would impact their buying decisions; which in turn would affect the buying decisions of their tens of thousands of social media followers. Of course, they were happy to oblige.

“Ignorance is NOT bliss,” Social Media Moms founder Kadi Prescott told me via Twitter. “How a food is made absolutely matters. Science matters. Way to bite the hands that feed you Chobani!”

Jessica Shyba of Momma’s Gone City was pretty clear why she doesn’t purchase Chobani as it is. “Their product is made with GMOs, right? Because THAT is why I don’t buy it. This [marketing] just feels tasteless and deceptive. Pun intended.”

Brands take note — making misleading claims on your marketing materials might not be the best idea. In this age of social media, consumers are quick to take a brand to task. Lack of planning, lack of checks and balances all contributed to a mistake that an already beleaguered company did not need. To their credit (and facing a lawsuit on labeling and a lawsuit on marketing), Chobani has been fairly quick in slyly explaining they may have let their marketing get out of hand.

A spokesman added in an email to Digiday, “We’re inviting all scientists to enjoy a Chobani on us: www.chobani.com/care.”

Still, #howmatters stands as a case study of a brand marketing campaign that expired before it even hit the back of the fridge.

  • LinkedIn Icon