Gerry Graf is the chief creative officer and a founder at creative agency Barton F. Graf, who’s worked at major creative shops like Goodby Silverstein & Partners, BBDO and Saatchi & Saatchi. On this episode of Starting Out, Graf discusses how rejection — a fact of life in advertising — has marked his career and more.
Ninety percent of a creative person’s life is rejection. It’s stock advertising. When you get an assignment, you go off on your own. You start coming up with ideas, and you personally kill half of all ideas. You’re the rejector. Then, you go sit down with your partner. You start throwing back and forth ideas. If you’re good, 90 percent of those will be rejected. Maybe if you’re good and hard on yourself, you will write down one out of 10.
Then, you have to go to the creative director. If they’re a good creative director, you come in with five to seven ideas; they’re going to reject at least half. Now, you have three. Then, you go to the client. Your job is to create, and sometimes, it feels like the client’s job is to reject.
It’s easy and safe to say no to something. It’s hard to say, “Yes, let’s do that.” Which is why when you go to people who are giving you the money to do it, it’s mostly rejection again. The job you’re paid money to do because you’re supposedly better at it — coming up with ideas — you have failed at it. That’s the life of a creative person.
I kept a journal when I worked at Goodby Silverstein. The third page says, “Oh, my God, I just sat in a room with Rich Silverstein.” Then, I flipped through seven months down through the journal. It says, “That old hag does not know what he’s talking about.” So I developed this sense that if I’m hard on myself, if I put the work in, then if you rejected my idea, then you’re an idiot.
Most ideas come from hard work. I was a stockbroker when I graduated out of college. When I moved to LA, I had bigger dreams. I think back to me on a bicycle with my portfolio, back in the old days going to every agency in Los Angeles and having them tell you, “These are horrible.”
I met somebody, Ken Fitzgerald, a creative director, who pointed at one ad in my book, and he’s like, “This one is good.” He told me why this was good. “Do more of those. Call me back.” Six months went by. When I did more of those, I went back, he showed the book to his boss, and his boss called Saatchi. In the early ’90s, I didn’t know what Saatchi versus Goodby was. Saatchi in ’91 had this junior intern creative program, and I got into that. I remember the excitement of doing it. I was getting paid as a writer.
You have to work longer than somebody else on the assignment. You need to exhaust every option. There are easy filters to get closer to great. If someone else has done that idea, then it’s dead. The funniest thing is you’ll get a lot more rejection from clients because nothing you’re going in with is safe. Try to push people. Get ready to say no. Get ready to dig a lot.
What beauty brand Fenty can gain from Rihanna’s Super Bowl halftime show
Following a roughly six-year hiatus from music, Rihanna is returning to headline the NFL Super Bowl halftime show. The residual effects for her Fenty brand will be paramount.
As destination travel takes off, the ‘Big Easy’ is experimenting with AR/VR to draw visitors
As travel, and travel tourism, return to pre-pandemic levels, New Orleans is leveraging AR/VR technology marketing to stand out and capture more traveler attention.
Why companies like iHeartMedia, NBCU rely on homegrown IP to build metaverse engagements
The success of recent brand activations is evidence that media and entertainment brands are the companies best equipped to build metaverse spaces that can dodge online skepticism, thanks to their wealth of owned IP.
SponsoredHow FAST channels are redefining primetime opportunities for advertisers
Sponsored by Vevo With the competition from content providers continuing to build, the traditional primetime TV slots are no longer guaranteeing the mass audiences they once did. Television viewership is evolving, and the primetime window of 8–11 p.m. is less broadly reflective of younger audiences’ content consumption habits. In 2022, attracting TV viewers is a […]
How sunglasses brand Quay retooled its advertising to be less reliant on performance marketing following iOS changes
Prior to the iOS changes, Quay was spending the majority of its ad dollars on performance marketing tactics and influencer marketing.
Skills shortages and legal uncertainty curtail marketers’ in-house ambitions for programmatic
IAB Europe survey reveals a significant in-housing slowdown with only 16% of marketers employing it as a model for programmatic trading.