Join us Dec. 1-3 in New Orleans for the Digiday Programmatic Marketing Summit
Intent vs. Social: There’s a question hanging over social media: Will personal relationships ever be as powerful as intent, at least when it comes to its role as an advertising signal? Judging by the valuations assigned to companies like Facebook, the answer is clearly yes. But Facebook has such a massive audience that it could make money off this in any number of ways. Search is unique. It is, in the words of ex-Yahoo CEO Terry Semel, “a beautiful system.” Google was able to return to us exactly what we’re looking for. The advertising problem, while not trivial, is pretty straightfoward. Intent-based ad signals have proven very valuable. Network connections are trickier. Jonathan Mendez, CEO of Yieldbot, reacted with a terse “bullshit” to the notion put forth by Buddy Media on the heels of its funding valuing it at $500 million that we’re moving from an intent-based world to a people-based world. Mendez points out that Google grew its revenue more in comparison to a year ago than Facebook is forecast to bring in this entire year. It’s clearly early, so that should change. Few expect the people-based world to replace search. But it should take away the prominence of its role as an information gatekeeper. Whether it’s monetized as effectively, that’s another story.
Quote of the Day: Yahoo’s ill-fated “It’s You” ad campaign is gone but not forgotten. One Business Insider reader summed it up thusly: “Calling the ‘It’s You’ campaign ‘horrible’ is like calling the Titanic a minor boating accident.”
Groupon Blues: Things move fast in the Web-darling world. Groupon has gone from digital wunderkind to posterboy for the bubble in a blink of an eye. The latest salvo against its business model comes from the Harvard Business Review. Keep in mind Groupon has already been termed a “Ponzi scheme,” so it should have pretty thick skin at this point. HBR is more gentle, simply saying it doesn’t have a viable business model. The problem, in HBR’s point of view, is Groupon hasn’t figured out how to turn a profit, yet it keeps expanding. HBR even brings up the dreaded Pets.com comparison.
More in Media
Shopify just became the biggest company to launch a Substack newsletter
Shopify is the first company of its kind — an e-commerce platform — to take the plunge into Substack.
News Corp explores multi-LLM licensing playbook
If News Corp were to strike multiple licensing deals, it would be a major signal to the market that the media group isn’t betting on one LLM; it’s building a portfolio and setting the terms.
Media Briefing: Associated Press deal cements Microsoft’s quiet rise in AI licensing
Associated Press has joined Microsoft’s AI content marketplace, as the tech company seeks to strengthen media ties and compete with Google.