Seven passes left to attend the Digiday Publishing Summit
Web advertising is a volume game, an arms race to ward off declining CPM prices. The way to combat that: create more Ms.
Web publishers talk a big game about cleaner, less cluttered sites, but when push comes to shove, they look to cram as many ad pixels as they can on pages. It’s not just bottom-feeders, either. Digiday took a look at some prominent sites to see how they stacked up in terms of the sheer volume of ad impressions they publish.
Based on the top 100 publishers by the number of ad impressions they served in February, ComScore cites publishers such as NY Daily News, Weather Underground, McClatchy, AutoGuide.com Group, and A+E Networks as some of the worst offenders in terms of the sheer number of display ad impressions they serve, on average, per page. NYDailyNews.com, for example, served an average of 4.2 in February. WeatherUnderground.com served slightly fewer, at an average of 3.7.
But those numbers are averages, calculated across every single page those properties serve. A glimpse at some of their content reveals the full extent of the ad clutter their pages actually include.
A search on Weather Underground for a New York City forecast, for example, loads a page with a total of nine IAB-standard banner ads. Each NYDailyNews.com article page carries five to six IAB units, in addition to ads for content on third-party sites, video ads, and a Meebo toolbar ad. Unsurprisingly, the vast majority of those display impressions appear to be filled by networks and exchanges.
These are not unique experiences. There are worse offenders out there, of course, that ComScore’s data fail to highlight because impressions are averaged across all of the pages they serve.
MailOnline.com also churns out five standard impressions on every article page, for example, but tops that up with non-standard Amazon ads and AdSense-like text ads littered around the page. Forbes.com serves up five or six standard display ads per article page in most instances, in addition to video ads, content ads and sometimes text ads. Across all of these publishers, ad units are often stacked on top of one another and, in some instances, feature the same creative.
ComScore’s list of the top 10 most prolific per-page ad publishers is below, but we welcome your input. Which sites have you seen that are chock-full of ads? Weigh in in the comments, or email me at the address listed below.
| Feb 2013 U.S. |
Display Ads per Total Pages |
| Mediatakeout.com |
9.0 |
| ZAM |
7.2 |
| Grooveshark |
5.1 |
| NYDailNews.com |
4.2 |
| Weather Underground |
3.7 |
| Move, Inc. Real Estate Sites |
3.4 |
| McClatchy Corporation |
3.3 |
| MediaNews Group |
3.3 |
| AutoGuide.com Group |
3.0 |
| A+E Networks Digital |
2.9 |
Image via Shutterstock
More in Media
Team hires, studio rental fees: The hidden costs of creators
The growth of the creator economy has empowered individuals to get into the business of media and entertainment with relatively few start-up costs. A camera, laptop and YouTube account are all one needs to upload their first video. But as creators become mainstream celebrities and scale up their business accordingly, they’ve started to incur more under-the-surface costs and fees, much like any media business.
Media Briefing: DOJ’s Google search trial remedies fall flat for publishers
The DOJ’s ruling means Google’s search engine remains deeply intertwined with AI, which some consider a “big win” for Google.
More money is flowing into creator marketing — just not directly to creators
Creators’ strategy regarding holiday marketing spending has shifted significantly, according to Collective Voice’s Holiday 2025 Creator Commerce Report. Sponsored content, once the lifeblood of creators’ brand revenue, is no longer the centerpiece, with 70 percent of creators saying traditional sponsored posts will make up less than a quarter of their holiday content.