The New York Times invites advertisers to the Page One edit meeting
Among traditional publishing companies, few have the journalistic heft of The New York Times. The 163-year-old institution has long had a strong moat around its newsroom to protect its journalistic integrity from business influences.
So one of the more interesting nuggets to come out of Digiday’s profile on The New York Times’ Meredith Kopit Levien (see full story here) was that the Times invites ad buyers to attend the storied daily Page One meeting, where editors decide what will go on the front page of the next day’s paper. Buyers have responded positively to the idea, which seems to go along with a greater willingness in general by the Times to let advertisers have contact with the editorial side.
Ben Winkler, chief digital officer at OMD, said that one of the first things Levien said to him upon joining the Times in 2013 was to invite him to attend a Page One meeting. “Talk about native advertising,” Winkler said. “To get behind the wall and see how the sausage has been made, that’s pretty special.”
The Times said it has a long history of having not just advertisers but various types of outsiders attend its Page One meetings as observers. (They are not to give input.) Stories of more advertisers visiting lately could be the function of a more aggressive sales team, a Times rep said.
There’s a trend toward newsrooms opening their Page One meetings to the public, which could include advertisers, to appear more transparent and help people understand the process, said Tom Rosenstiel, executive director of the American Press Institute and a longtime observer of news ethics. Two prominent examples are the former McClatchy newspaper chain and CBS News.
In addition to bringing people into the process, opening up the Page One meetings improves the quality of the events, which could otherwise have a tendency to have participants “sucking up to the main decision-maker,” Rosenstiel said. On the other hand, he said, “If it’s done in way that only special advertising people get in and not everyone, that’s a little more peculiar.”
Digiday did some checking, and the practice is less common at other traditional news organizations. The Wall Street Journal doesn’t open its meetings to advertisers (only occasionally student groups and visiting reporters). The Washington Post opens the meeting to newsroom guests, and only very rarely, ad clients. The New York Daily News doesn’t open its meeting to any outsiders. Executives at Time Inc. said they are unaware of any clients or advertisers sitting in on editorial meetings.
“We often talk about how we approach editorial and distribution, but I can’t think of any instance in which we had clients sit in on actual meetings,” said Business Insider editor-in-chief Henry Blodget.
The same is true at International Business Times, said Peter Goodman, global editor-in-chief.
“We have no interaction with agencies or clients within the confines of our newsroom,” he said. “We have a very traditional church-state division, and we see this as crucial to preserve our integrity and our relationship with readers. We believe that journalists have to do their jobs free of commercial interests, and that’s actually best for the business side: If we are given the freedom to produce the most compelling, hard-hitting journalism we can, absent any conflicts of interests, we will win readers and the business side will have something powerful to sell.”
‘Total whack a mole’: Rogue political ads create mounting brand safety problems for publishers
The political ads flowing through open exchanges are creating a brand safety dilemma, despite the safeguards put in place.
‘An election night that could last weeks’: How news publishers are updating their digital strategies for the results long haul
Before they are able to make their call on who wins the presidency, news publishers could have a month-and-a-half past Nov.3 to compete for audiences.
‘Asymmetrical in every sense’: The latest console wars see Sony and Microsoft pursue diverging battle plans
The console wars are back, setting the stage for the latest bout in the long-running battle between Sony’s Playstation and Microsoft’s Xbox brands.
SponsoredB2B events were broken before the pandemic, their online reinvention is creating positive change
Kim Darling, executive producer, Inbound Farewell lanyards, business cards and branded pens — it’ll be some time before people get their hands on these souvenirs of in-person events again. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to transform the way people work, buy, sell, socialize and entertain themselves, the global events industry is facing its biggest-ever challenge. […]
‘Walk before you run’: Sports publishers look to blow out their betting content
Over the past 12 months, several large sports media brands have signed partnership deals with sports books
‘It’s a virtuous cycle’: Audiences and advertisers seek health and wellness content and publishers are seeing green
Publishers are building new content products that give audiences more health and wellness content and advertisers more partner opportunities.