Declining Facebook reach squeezes publishers’ branded-content business
The decline of organic reach on Facebook is affecting publishers’ branded-content studios, too.
Over the past six months, the amount of money publishers spent to distribute branded content on Facebook has risen dramatically, according to Keywee, a content marketing tool. In the fourth quarter of 2017, spending on branded-content distribution leapt 159 percent year over year. Spending grew 231 percent year over year in the prior quarter, according to Keywee. The company wouldn’t share raw dollar figures associated with the increases.
To some extent, that uptick was driven by growth in branded content, with more content studios producing more campaigns that require more paid distribution. Worldwide spend on branded content totaled $5 billion in 2017, according to estimates from branded content distributor Polar, up from $3.6 billion in 2016. But higher prices played a role, too. Over the past two months, the cost per click publishers pay for Facebook ads grew 16 percent year over year, per Keywee.
And with organic reach expected to continue dropping and brands holding publishers to higher standards when it comes to their content distribution, the pressure on publishers’ branded-content margins is likely to grow.
“Everybody understands Facebook’s been tightening the algorithm a bit,” said Chris McLoughlin, svp of The Foundry, a branded-content studio at publishing company Meredith. “It’s going to mean margin pressure for those who relied exclusively on organic distribution.”
Facebook’s audience targeting has helped publishers expand their audience reach outside their own properties.
“[Publishers] now recognize that users coming from the paid channel are more engaged,” said Jared Lansky, Keywee’s chief strategy officer. “Instead of selling a $50,000 deal against your organic distribution, you can sell a quarter-million-dollar deal against Facebook distribution.”
But there are trade-offs. The first is declining organic reach, which requires publishers to spend more to get the same level of reach they once expected to get for free. Eytan Elbaz, CEO of Cooking Panda, said that while most of his branded-content distribution is organic, his company has had to pay a “noticeable but not game-changing” increase to get the same reach it once got organically.
The second reason for the increased cost is more scrutiny from brands and agencies. They’re demanding more detail about the people their content reached, even suggesting audience segments of their own for publishers to use, which can increase the price further, even if there are also fewer wasted impressions for the brands, said Melanie Deziel, a branded-content consultant who used to be a branded-content editor at The New York Times and HuffPost.
Executives including McLoughlin say they have yet to see the kind of apocalyptic drop in reach that some were predicting after Facebook announced it would show less publisher content to users in their news feeds. But even if that drop occurs, publishers expect that advertisers will keep using publishers to create branded content and, given Facebook’s targeting capabilities, use the platform to distribute it.
“Given the success that we’ve had with content that we create with our brand partners, we’re not surprised that brands are spending more dollars for Facebook distribution,” said Oren Katzeff, head of programming at Tastemade.
How entertainment publishers are adapting their coverage
Coronavirus may have upended Bustle Digital Group's, People's and BuzzFeed's editorial schedules, but now the publishers creating new franchises out of the pandemic.
With ad rates falling, Snopes can’t keep up with coronavirus misinformation
Snopes had a 50% increase in traffic over the past 30 days, but dwindling ad revenue and a lack of resources is preventing the company from staffing up to combat coronavirus misinformation.
‘We’re looking at this as an opportunity’: Bloomberg Media CEO Justin Smith’s optimistic scenario for media’s recovery
"I just heard this morning from a colleague that was saying that the first couple of weeks are definitely the most difficult": Bloomberg Media CEO Justin Smith.
SponsoredSurvey: The threats of deceptive ads in 2020
Publishers and advertisers: How are you planning to block, eliminate and avoid deceptive ads in 2020? How will deceptive ads impact the 2020 election? Are you seeing deceptive ads that exploit the coronavirus crisis? Take this short survey and we’ll provide the results.
‘Embracing the imperfections’: The test kitchen is now a WFH kitchen
Tastemade, Meredith and the NYT Cooking grapple with what remote working will mean for their production schedules.
Member ExclusiveMedia enters the realm of unknown unknowns
In conversations with several media executives in the past 10 days, we are now firmly in the grip of the known unknowns and unknown unknowns.