9 seats left:

Join us Dec. 1-3 in New Orleans for the Digiday Programmatic Marketing Summit

SECURE YOUR SEAT

Algorithms Can’t Replace Editorial Judgment

Sean O’Neal is the global CMO of Mail Online.

The quantity of content that is available today online is daunting. In the last 10 years, more editorial content has been distributed on the Internet than in all other forms of media over the previous 100 years. Traditional publishers, bloggers, curators, aggregators and even automated programs are filling the Web with billions of pieces of content every day. Some of it is designed simply to grab the attention of search engines in order to produce page views against which ads can be sold. That content can be vapid and transparent for its intent.

Let’s focus for the moment on real stories generated by real journalists and how technology can help them make packaging decisions that enhance their media brand.

Much like in the world of advertising, there are now powerful technologies that enable
publishers to generate, measure and optimize the content they develop, and where, when and how they distribute it. Analytics programs can inform on trending topics in real time, readership data can help optimize engagement rates and algorithms can help determine the best placements of text, photos and video for maximum exposure. The end result is an editorial experience “optimized” by readers who, with their attention, “vote” on the stories they like best. These are incredible advancements in media, and the savviest publishers are embracing them.

These tools provide for incremental reading environment improvements, but they are not a substitution for editorial instinct. The most brilliant journalists have spent years honing their craft. Investigative reporting, disciplined fact-checking and editorial integrity are real, and they cannot be programmed. The intuition that leads a reporter to a scoop, the feeling that a story should or should not be published, the sense of timing that can only come from years of disciplined journalism — these are the human qualities that connect us to great editorial.

And they are rare and special qualities. So what happens when a publisher possesses these talents as well as a black belt in data, analytics and content optimization? Media evolves. Consumer value increases. Marketing opportunities are transformed.

The technology-driven ways of optimizing content in new media are not a threat to publishing. Quite the opposite. They present an exciting opportunity for advancement. But the opportunity is truly realized when driven by that editorial “gut” that can only come from the human experience.

Image via Shutterstock

More in Media

shopping laptop

Shopify just became the biggest company to launch a Substack newsletter

Shopify is the first company of its kind — an e-commerce platform — to take the plunge into Substack.

Graphic of a dollar sign-shaped key unlocking a lock, symbolizing the key to unlocking successful performance marketing through the seven stages of development

News Corp explores multi-LLM licensing playbook

If News Corp were to strike multiple licensing deals, it would be a major signal to the market that the media group isn’t betting on one LLM; it’s building a portfolio and setting the terms. 

Media Briefing: Associated Press deal cements Microsoft’s quiet rise in AI licensing

Associated Press has joined Microsoft’s AI content marketplace, as the tech company seeks to strengthen media ties and compete with Google.