WTF is the CCPA’s definition of sale?
The California Consumer Privacy Act contains many ambiguities that have confounded companies in their compliance efforts. But considering the fact that the privacy law is centered on providing people control over how their personal information is sold, the CCPA’s most enigmatic element is also its most important: What is considered a sale of someone’s personal information?
What exactly represents a sale of personal information under the law, which went into effect at the start of the year, “needs to be more widely talked about because people are probably breaking the CCPA without knowing it,” said privacy consultant Debbie Reynolds, CEO of Debbie Reynolds Consulting. “They may be thinking about sale in the strict, traditional sense,” added Reynolds, who previously served as the data privacy officer at law firm Eimer Stahl.
WTF is the CCPA’s definition of sale?
The CCPA defines a sale as the exchange of someone’s personal information for money “or other valuable consideration.” In other words, its definition of sale is not as straightforward as stating that it is a literal sale in which personal information is directly traded for dollars.
What does “other valuable consideration” mean?
It’s unclear. The law does not define what is meant by “valuable consideration.” As a result, companies and their lawyers are left to interpret that language and how it might apply to their businesses. This poses a particular problem for companies that buy, sell or facilitate the sale of targeted advertising.
Why is the definition of a sale an issue for companies in the targeted advertising business?
Many of the types of data that publishers, ad tech companies and advertisers use to target ads are considered personal information under the CCPA. The law explicitly cites cookies, mobile ad IDs and IP addresses as forms of personal information. Therefore, if one company shares that information with another company in order to buy or sell a targeted ad impression, that activity could be considered a sale of personal information under the privacy law.
“There’s a clear fault line between the way the [online advertising] industry views cookie sharing, which is more like sharing and not a sale, and the way consumer groups are articulating their belief, which is, if the cookie is going to track the consumer across the internet on nonowned-and-operated properties, that would constitute a sale,” said Dominique Shelton Leipzig, co-chair of the ad tech privacy and data management practice at law firm Perkins Coie.
Does that mean a publisher selling targeted ads is technically selling personal information?
Maybe. Publishers have diverged in their interpretation of the CCPA’s definition of sale. Some publishers have adopted the strict interpretation that they do sell data under the law. But other publishers have asserted that the law is not clear enough about whether the use of tracking mechanisms like cookies constitutes a sale of people’s personal information.
“A lot of times when people are doing targeted advertising, they’re using other companies,” Reynolds said. “So the fact that there is an exchange or dissemination of that information and some monetary or valuable gain, [that] would, in my view, constitute a sale.”
What do companies that sell personal information under the CCPA need to do?
These companies are required to take several actions if they sell California residents’ personal information. These firms must display a “clear and conspicuous” link on their homepages titled “Do Not Sell My Personal Information” so that users can request that they stop selling their information. Additionally, these companies must provide users a list of the types of businesses where their data has been sold.
Is there a way for companies to share personal information with other businesses without this constituting a sale?
Yes, a company can designate another company as a service provider. This allows a publisher, for example, to share a California resident’s IP address with an ad tech company in order to sell a targeted ad. But the ad tech company would be able to use that IP address only to facilitate the sale of the targeted ad. The ad tech company would not be allowed to add that data point to its device graph that it uses to sell targeted ads for other publishers.
When will there be any clarity about what counts as a sale?
This is also unclear. “Ultimately certain things are not going to be made any more clear in the [regulations], and my prediction is we’ll be seeing this play out” in court, Shelton Leipzig said.
Member ExclusiveDigiday+ Research: Most brands haven’t let supply chain concerns influence their holiday promotions
As the supply chain’s problems have grown into a clear obstacle for many brands and retailers, that shift hasn’t been enough to drastically change the holiday promotion strategies for a majority of brands, according to new Digiday+ research.
‘It really comes down to reach and frequency’: TV execs sound off at Advertising Week on audience fragmentation
With more ways to watch video, audiences are becoming fragmented. At this year's Advertising Week, television executives talk streamlining viewership data points, the future of targeting and more.
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: ‘We’ve had to pivot, pause, and adjust’: How supply chain issues are causing marketers to change Q4 and holiday advertising plans
Marketers and agency execs say that the impact is already palpable. For those struggling with supply chain issues -- brought about by the bottleneck of cargo ships -- the lack of new products to promote or stock issues is making them rethink how much they are advertising now as well as retooling Black Friday Cyber Monday plans.
SponsoredQuestion of the Day: The state of the holiday season for publishers
The Digiday Publishing Summit brought leaders in the world of media companies together with the platform and technology partners that work with them. Across the course of three days in Miami, in September 2021, experts and executives framed the state of publishing — identifying trends and next steps to follow in the year to come. In […]
TikTok creators with mid-level reach may be the most effective for brand partnerships
Brands that worked with creators in with mid-tier (11 million) and lower (540,000) follower counts received the best levels of attention, as opposed to the creators with the largest followings.
How WFH is taking its toll on our physical wellness
Not only have anxiety and depression become concerns among the workforce but so have physical ailments like exhaustion, aches and pains, headaches, digestive problems and high blood pressure, since permanent working from home was enforced.