Only a team as perpetually down on its luck as the Chicago Cubs could see a well-intentioned rebranding so horribly backfire.
Earlier this week, the Cubs — one of Major League Baseball’s oldest, most venerated franchises — unveiled Clark, its fuzzy new bear cub mascot, the first in team history. The team brought Clark and several of its top young prospects to the Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center to bring cheer to Chicago children suffering from developmental disorders. “From the looks of things, everyone had a good time,” MLB.com reported.
Well, maybe not everyone.
“Clark is the Cubs equivalent of Scrappy Doo,” Larry Vincent, self-proclaimed Cubs fan and executive director of the Brand Studio at the United Talent Agency, told Digiday.
“It just doesn’t feel like the Chicago Cubs brand,” Mark Pasetsky, CEO of public relations agency Mark Allen & Company, said. “This is a team that has a very deep, rich history and having this laughable mascot goes against that.”
The Internet’s reception was colder than a Chicago ice storm. Gawker Media’s sports blog Deadspin immediately criticized Clark’s introduction, calling him “a nightmarish, perverted furry.” The site then called for its readers to submit defaced versions of the Clark logo, a request readers responded to quickly, profanely and en masse. Perhaps the most stinging zinger was from the reader who turned Clark into a goat, a reference to the “curse of the billy goat” that has haunted the Cubs since 1945.
The Cubs are standing by the mascot, saying that the digital backlash is a mere flash in the pan.
“The Internet is bored all the time, and we certainly gave it a shot of adrenaline on Monday. This is no big deal,” Julian Green, the Cubs’s vp of communications and community affairs, said.
Green added that the Cubs began developing Clark last year as a way to address fans’ concerns about the lack of family-friendly options at Wrigley Field.
“We have a core base of customers that are parents who themselves grew up as Cubs fans and now bringing their kids to Wrigley Field,” he said.
Green stressed that Clark is intended for kids. But the problem with any brand trying to broaden its appeal is that it risks alienating its core base. The Cubs brand is about tradition, and introducing a mascot to a fanbase that prides itself on more than 100 years of legacy doesn’t exactly coincide with that image.
“As with most brands, when you do a new product introduction, you run some risks,” Green said. “But the product has not changed. Cubs baseball and Wrigley Field and their pride, tradition and history will remain.”
Green added that the team’s historic World Series drought has given the Cubs a thick skin. If the Cubs’s charm does emanate from the team being a tough yet lovable loser, then Clark is certainly on-brand at the moment.
Inside ESPN’s campaign to get fantasy football players to sign up for its upcoming season
ESPN and BSSP have teamed up for their first live-action collaboration on a new campaign to attract fantasy football players.
How brands and creators are using Roblox’s new Materials tool to boost the realism of their virtual worlds
Roblox has been beta testing its new Materials tools for several months, but officially launched the update in late July. Users now have the ability to build with materials and textures that more accurately represent the physical world.
Why cannabis company Curaleaf wants to ‘integrate into culture’ to build its brands
Curaleaf is one of a number of cannabis brands aiming to take a CPG approach and normalize cannabis while dealing with advertising restrictions as the industry continues to grow.
SponsoredConsumers expect brands to be authentic in their DE&I commitments
Sponsored by Amazon Ads With consumers looking to brands to take stances on global and social issues that impact their lives, it’s hard to argue the important role brands play in our society. With this great opportunity also comes great responsibility, and consumers are paying attention. New research commissioned by Amazon Ads with Environics Research […]
How Pinterest hopes to catch up to the e-commerce boom
Long before the pandemic-driven e-commerce boom, marketers saw a gold mine in Pinterest that many felt was left nascent. But as the platform has hastened its expansion of advertising offerings, media buyers say it has a ways to go to compete with every other platform entering the commerce race.
As Google’s demise of third-party cookies drags, debate over seller-defined audiences hardens
Seller-defined audiences are one of a cacophony of alternatives to third-party cookies that have the potential to make headway after Google delayed the death of the cookie again. But SDAs' path is not clear-cut.