The dog-and-pony show: Startups’ frustrations working with agencies
Startups are undeniably cool now, so it’s no surprise agencies are often touting their work with up-and-comers.
Those partnerships sound fruitful for both sides in theory: Startups can access agencies’ clients and their marketing experience, while agencies can keep abreast of the hottest marketing trends. But in reality, agencies too often over-promise and under-deliver – and the stop-and-start nature of the agency world can be maddening to time- and resource-strapped startups.
“One of the biggest frustrations I’ve seen between startups and agencies is rooted in the repeated dog-and-pony shows,” said one entrepreneur. “Agencies love to bring startups in, have them pitch their wares, and often do so repeatedly for their internal teams and for their clients — all with little apparent ROI for the startup.”
Most of those “dog-and-pony shows” are just exploratory and educational for agencies, in the form of both phone calls and presentations to small groups, he explained. And it often takes a long time for a deal to materialize due to the educational process and the fact that many big brands don’t move fast — their budgets are planned well in advance.
“It’s truly a sales process, and agencies are part of it,” said the entrepreneur. “Startups just need to be persistent and remain patient. If you’re good at what you do, are offering something valuable, and stay engaged, it can pay off in big ways.”
It can, but agencies have a very different business model. A meeting that goes nowhere for a startup is an opportunity cost, but for an agency it’s just more billable hours.
Chico Tirado, co-founder and chief revenue officer for influencer marketing startup Gnack, added that agencies are always under pressure to perform due to their clients’ requests (which are sometimes very sudden). This sometimes means “vetting a lot of service providers and not actually working with them.”
Clients can also simply kill projects. After all, the old joke is that clients want something that’s never been done before but with guaranteed ROI.
“Many of our agency partners go very far down the road of what would normally be a full campaign, only to lose the pitch, or have the advertiser client pull the best ideas and then execute in-house,” said Dave McIninch, chief revenue officer of performance marketing startup Acquisio. “This is part of the reason why agencies are guarded about showing a technology as a standalone to their clients — the ROI for the agency isn’t there.”
Another reason why agencies are slow in introducing startups to brand advertisers is that they often want to present a polished plan to their brand clients, so introducing a startup that is inexperienced in presenting could reflect poorly on the agency. Additionally, agencies sometimes like to use startups as a “surprise and delight” later on in the process, benefiting the agency but not the startup as minimal budget exists after a certain point in the planning phase, said Ben Kosinski, director of the Collaboratory at agency iCrossing.
“I think agencies need to understand that time is a constraint — a startup cannot wait for four months for an idea to come to fruition,” said Kosinski. “Agencies need a person who understands the startup community as a liaison.”
‘We want our brands to be where people are’: As gaming becomes a culture touchstone, advertisers toggle in
As the gaming audience grows, advertisers have a new batch of businesses pursuing their media dollars — video game developers.
Member Exclusive‘Cyber Monday has become Cyber November’: How the digital shopping day’s evolution is affecting marketers
Even if it’s a logical move to stretch out discounts typically reserved for Cyber Monday, it can create a more difficult environment for marketers.
How Roblox is paving the way for a new era of branded gaming
Roblox is still in its infancy as a marketing tool. But over the last two years, the number of brands and retailers on Roblox has grown dramatically.
SponsoredWhy ad buyers (and sellers) need to pay more attention to viewer attention
By Yan Liu, CEO, TVision Like the proverbial tree falling in the forest, we all recognize that oftentimes the TV is on, but no one is in the room to hear or see it. And yet some ad buyers continue to rely on a metric that fails to account for this. To mix metaphors, buyers […]
‘Email has become so cluttered’: Why DTC brands plan to use texting for Black Friday and Cyber Monday this year
With Black Friday and Cyber Monday nearing, text messaging is becoming a more common marketing channel for direct-to-consumer brands.
‘There’s more opportunity’: Publishers on TikTok are taking branded content into their own hands
As their audiences on the social app have grown, a flurry of publishers have turned to developing branded content campaigns to explore new commercial opportunities.