What The Guardian has learned from chatbots
For the past two months, the Guardian has been testing a Facebook Messenger bot, “Sous-chef,” that provides recipe suggestions to people based on what they had in their fridges. Now, it’s using the learnings to shape its main news bot, which launched a week ago.
It’s too early to get data on how many people are actively using the news app, though the Guardian’s 6.2 million Facebook followers all have access to the bot.
We spoke to Martin Belam, The Guardian’s social and new formats editor; and Chris Wilk, group product manager for off-platform, about what they’ve learned. Here are the takeaways:
Keep it simple
The bot has a simple setup: Users enter specific ingredients like “salmon” or types of cuisine, dietary requirements, and specific dishes, to get started. The bot responds with recipes from the Guardian’s archive and witty messages like: “Did I crack it for you?” or “Ok, results are on the boil.”
One sticking point with bots is they aren’t sophisticated enough to handle natural language and misspellings, like “Yeh” and “yum.” So the Guardian switched to a natural language processing tool Wit.ai, which can be trained to handle more types of answers.
A lot of users responded as they would to a human, and when they got non-human responses, they’d stop using it, said Wilk. So the Guardian went in the opposite direction with its news bot and aimed for utter simplicity. The lesson, according to Wilk, was: “Don’t build people’s expectations too much of what’s possible, just keep it simple.”
Alerts based on time rather than breaking news
A number of publishers including CNN have sent out bot alerts based on what’s breaking. The Guardian chose to send alerts based on time of day to see if sending out alerts at the same time every day will help make the bot habit-forming. So a user can choose if they want news updates sent at 6, 7 or 8 a.m.
Once the time is chosen, the bot sends out the five main stories that lead the Guardian’s home page. The bot is only being tested in the U.K., but if a user flies to a different time zone, the alerts will be adjusted to the new local time zone.
Publisher have to strike the right tone when creating products to live on others’ platforms, so users still know who’s bringing them the information. It’s hard to get the balance right with an automated bot. People can be turned off if the experience is too robot-like or casual, so the Guardian opted for polite.
People still want bots to be bots
When testing Sous-chef internally, The Guardian wanted to see how people would react to very human-like responses. The tech isn’t there to do this yet, so the Guardian had in-house engineers and UX experts manually respond to questions posed by staffers who’d been recruited to test the bot. Their reactions showed that people may not be ready for bots that are too human-like. “You don’t want to be too formal and robotic in the responses because it can be boring and not engage people, but if you try and be too human people get freaked out more by that,” Wilk said.
How The 19th relied on memberships and funding to launch during a pandemic
In order to keep on schedule to launch ahead of the U.S. presidential election, non-profit publisher The 19th had to rely heavily on membership and fundraising to meet its launch goal of $4 million.
‘Let the buyers know you exist’: How Morning Brew plans to grow brand ad dollars from its base of direct response
Direct-response ads accounted for 90% of Morning Brew's 2019 revenue in 2019. Its CEO wants brand advertising to account for 50% by the end of 2021.
‘A significant uptick in deal flow’: Why Europe is becoming a hotbed of ad tech innovation
Ad tech companies with data privacy and identity solutions are in vogue among the sector's investors and acquirers.
SponsoredPublishers: Assessing risk and ensuring payments in times of crisis
As the industry navigates the continued impacts of COVID-19, here’s the questions publishers should ask their programmatic partners or ad management providers to protect themselves from clawbacks and lost revenue.
‘We can be agile and evolve’: News UK is quickly growing a 7-figure incremental revenue stream from social video
The goal for Social Studio is a 10-day turnaround from campaign booking to going live.
Lack of events revenue squeezes B2B media, forcing virtual volume — and innovation
Advertising, subscriptions and commerce have begun to recover. But events have not, and B2B media companies are feeling the squeeze.