The Great Twitter Undercount


The Great Twitter Undercount: All publishers and brands are keeping an eye on their referrals. The indirect traffic sources typically make up more than half of all visitors. For years Google dominated the referral game. Entire media enterprises — see Demand Media — were created with the proposition of catering to the Google algorithm. Slowly but surely, social media has become an important way people are finding content. But how big is that shift? Twitter is devilishly hard to track because of the distributed nature of its open platform. At All Things D, Twitter tracking service founder Jonathan Strauss estimates Twitter is credited with just 25 percent of the traffic it actually drives. That would make it a much more important source for publishers and brands. It matters since the bigger the source a referrer is, the greater a part it plays in a publisher’s strategy.

Google+ as Existential Threat to Tumblr, Twitter: Google+’s blockbuster growth — Google execs confirmed it passed 10 million users — has naturally led to the conclusion that it’s a mortal threat to Facebook. But that might not be the case. In fact, with the flow of content on Google+ it might be more of a threat to content-consumption networks like Twitter and Tumblr. John Battelle makes the point that Google is creating a vast amount of “conversational marketing” inventory with its stream of content. The stream itself closely resembles the logic of Twitter and Tumblr. Facebook is somewhat different. Yes, it’s sharing content but it is moving to become something more: the technical infrastructure that powers the socialization of the Web. If Battelle’s right, Google+ might cause more worries for Twitter and Tumblr than Facebook.

Stat of the Day: Things change fast on the Web. In 2004, AOL boasted 23 million users to Facebook’s 1 million. By 2010, AOL was down to 1 million while Facebook was at 600 million and counting.

Web Ads and Annoyance: The basic problem of the Web for marketers is how it fragments consumer attention. The blunt-force solution for many to this point has been ever more intrusive ads. Many in the industry end up arguing these ads aren’t any worse than TV. The problem, of course, is context. As the Advertising Research Federation’s Ted McConnell notes, the Web is more task-oriented, leading to a high “opportunity to annoy.” Time and again, Web ads are ranked higher in annoyance than traditional placements. The problem is even greater when it comes to social media platforms, where the main function is communication, a time that’s hardly ideal for commercial interruption.

Ditching It All: There are times that many in the media and marketing world dream of quitting and moving to a quiet place to tend to grapes. It’s a nearly cliche pipe dream. Not so for Regan Meador, a senior strategist at EuroRSCG. He’s really quitting to tend to the grapes. He’s leaving the agency business to become a winemaker’s assistant on North Fork, Long Island.

More in Media

Publisher execs talk AI licensing deals, new applications for AI in latest earnings calls

Publicly-traded media companies touted new deals with generative AI tech companies and other new applications for the technology in their Q1 2024 earnings calls.

Transparency shift: CMOs navigate new norms in agency profit models

Many CMOs seem to be okay with their agencies finding new ways to increase margins, as long as the process is transparent, or at least openly acknowledges a lack of transparency.

Media Briefing: Publishers’ Q1 earnings show promise, but also room for improvement

Publishers’ Q1 earnings show some promise in the digital ad market.