How publishers navigate the ethics of live events
As print advertising dries up, many media companies are finding live events to be a welcome revenue source. Events can help connect advertisers with target consumers, enhance the host’s reputation with its audience and generate editorial content for its platforms. But they’re also fraught with ethical issues, as The Washington Post found out in 2009 when it tried to sell lobbyists access to salons where for $25,000 a sponsor could get facetime with government officials and Post journalists (a practice which also cast scrutiny on The Atlantic’s salons). The Post now has these guidelines addressing newsroom involvement in events.
The inherent challenge is to get sponsors to pay big bucks without letting them influence the event agenda itself, by their presence on stage or off-the-record rules for journalists there. There’s also the slippery slope of having editorial involved. While it’s a good idea in theory to use your expert journalists to set the agenda, there’s the temptation to use the power to curry favor with sources.
“It could appear, either to the sponsors or the people who are coming, that they’re getting some special access to the reporter,” said Kelly McBride, Poynter’s resident ethics expert. “Then, people think the news is for sale.” Publishing companies today are all over the map in how they’re approaching these inherent tensions. (Digiday is no exception. Digiday editors program and participate in events, and sponsors can present during sponsor content sessions. Event sessions, other than “town halls,” are on the record.) Here’s a sampling:
Pitch: AtlanticLive events, like the Aspen Ideas Festival, convene leaders across industries for stimulating gatherings that “bring the brand to life.”
Journalist participation: According The Atlantic’s exhaustive guidelines (one of the few to be posted online), its journalists are encouraged to participate and attend but may not be pressured to do so.
Sponsor involvement: Underwriters are clearly communicated to event attendees. Sponsors must be called “underwriters” and not “co-host.” They may participate on panels if they have no economic interest in the outcome, or if an opposing view is included, among other stipulations.
Programming: The Atlantic’s journalists have final say over the content. Unusual for a media company, the events division falls under the oversight of Bob Cohn, former Atlantic digital editor who recently was promoted to co-president of The Atlantic.
On the record: Public policy events are on the record or on background, meaning journalists can report but not attribute comments to specific people.
The New York Times
Pitch: Thought-leadership events offer sponsors “extensive digital and print promotion, radio and on-site exposure, sampling and literature distribution opportunities, extensive press efforts and custom programs.”
Journalist participation: Not required.
Sponsor involvement: They’re not on panels unless they’re coincidentally picked by edit team that independently creates the program.
Programming: By staff overseen by the GM and editorial director of conferences, who, the Times points out, used to be the editor of The New York Times Magazine.
On the record: All conferences are on the record.
Pitch: Events like Most Powerful Women and Brainstorm are pitched as events where business people can rub shoulders with government officials and thought leaders.
Journalist participation: Reporters and editors attend but aren’t required to participate.
Sponsor involvement: Speaking roles aren’t sold as a benefit of sponsorship, but sponsors may be asked to be on the agenda if editorial deems them suitable, which happened when AT&T sponsored Fortune Brainstorm Tech and editorial invited AT&T’s chairman and CEO to sit on a panel.
Programming: Editorial decides the programming.
On the record: All events are on the record.
TechCrunch (Disrupt, Engadget’s Expand)
Pitch: Disrupt is promoted as a way for vendors to expose their products to potential clients, investors and, yes, members of the press.
Programming: The editorial side sets the agenda.
Sponsor involvement: Sponsors can buy a booth and go to networking events, but aren’t included in programming. “Sponsors can’t buy their way on stage,” said Ned Desmond, COO, TechCrunch.
On the record: All events are on the record. Events are live-streamed. Participation in Startup Battlefield, a competition for early-stage companies, is free.
Other: TechCrunch has an anti-harassment policy prohibiting “overly sexualized” comments during talks and sexualized content by exhibitors, presumably to prevent embarrassing snafus like the 2013 “Titstare” incident.
The Washington Post
Pitch: The Washington Post Live, the Post’s conference and events series, is promoted as a “high-profile platform for advancing solutions to critical problems.”
Programming: Editorial directs all content.
Sponsor involvement: They may make introductory remarks; if they’re newsmakers, they may be asked by edit to be on panels.
On the record: Post events are on the record; journalists should have editor approval to participate in others’ on-background events
The New Yorker
Pitch: Its signature event, the 15-year-old New Yorker Festival, hardly needs to promote itself as the literary, political and cultural smorgasbord for the intelligentsia it is.
Programming: Editorial decides the speakers and agenda.
Sponsor involvement: Sponsors can’t participate in the festival (although the content doesn’t quite lend itself to sponsors like Acura and Mastercard, two of this year’s festival backers.)
On the record: The event is open to the public and on the record.
Image via Flickr
Cheat Sheet: At IAB Podcast Upfront, diverse voices take center stage while podcast advertising revenue and audiences boom
Most of the companies that presented at the IAB Podcast Upfront signaled they had or were going to add more diversity to their programming, both in hosts and content.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: What media companies’ latest earnings reports say about the state of the industry
Media companies' Q1 earnings reports signaled a continued return to business as usual — for better or worse, depending on the company's digital business.
‘Brands tend to be selective’: OMG report offers options to media buyers facing upfront inventory crunch
With a tight upfront TV marketplace expected, one agency group is recommending alternatives in video and CTV.
SponsoredHow The Company Store is reimagining customer experiences for pandemic-era growth
Throughout the pandemic, some retail categories have been inherently successful. Home furnishings and décor are among them; with consumers spending so much more time at home, updates and renovations flourished. Criteo data from the first half of 2020 showed sales for items like outdoor furniture sets up 434% year over year, with other home items […]
‘You’re fixing a number, not changing the culture’: Confessions of a media exec on diversity quotas
In the rush to improve diversity rates, businesses are in danger of overlooking more fundamental ways to sustain inclusivity in the workplace, according to our latest Confessions interviewee.
‘Direct revenue driver’: How local broadcaster News 12 is partnering with Google to build a younger audience
Local broadcaster used support and funding from Google News Initiative to build a new tool that can automatically identify and feed video content into new website verticals.