Google’s homepage has a new look, at least for read-it-later app Pocket’s users. The app, which has raised $14.5 million according to Crunchbase, has a new Google Chrome extension that shows “trending articles” recommendations in a tray automatically inserted for users who open a new tab with Google’s homepage.
The strategy is a legal gray area according to cyberlaw experts since Pocket doesn’t have a deal with Google. It also raises the question of whether Google will block the extension from altering the appearance of its page. (Google declined to comment specifically on this question.)
“There is no definite answer one way or the other [if the widgets are legal],” said Mark Bartholomew, a SUNY-Buffalo law professor who specializes in advertising law. “The law hasn’t caught up with addressing add-ons and widgets.”
Last week, Pocket launched a few new features, including a recommendation widget that pops up under the search bar when users with the Pocket extension open a tab on Google Chrome. Pocket plans to roll out similar widgets for Safari and Microsoft Edge by the end of the year.
Pocket’s Chrome extension has been downloaded 3 million times, and the widget has displayed content from about 260 publishers.
The recommendations are driven by which articles are being saved and read the most on Pocket, and publishers can’t pay to have their stories promoted in the widget, said Nate Weiner, Pocket CEO and founder. The company is also having internal discussions on how to expand their widgets to social platforms, even though several premium publishers such as Slate and The New Yorker are ditching their suggested-content boxes amid pushback from irritated users.
“The stuff you see at the bottom of those sites isn’t great,” Weiner said. “They’re actually terrible in a lot of ways. We’re trying to prove you can drive recommendation to quality stuff that users trust.”
Although Google has been successful in stopping pop-ups and maintaining a clean homepage, consumers are less likely to be confused by Pocket’s widgets since they only show up for users who opted into the extension, Bartholomew said. Unless the widgets start interfering with the search bar’s functionality, it’s unlikely that the FCC will get involved, he added.
“But I think Google would be eyeing this cautiously,” he said. “They don’t have the strongest case here, but they do have a brand to protect.”
Frederick Lane, an attorney and author who writes about emerging technologies, said that there is a growing trend among extensions that insert content onto other websites.
“It is a legal gray area, but I don’t think it is consumer confusion,” he said. “It is more accurately described as adware, although it is a fairly mild example.”
Although people like to complain about Outbrain and Taboola links, Slate and The New Yorker are outliers when it comes to dumping recommendation widgets. A recent study from ChangeAdvertising.org found that 82 percent of the top 50 news websites used ads from players like Taboola and Outbrain.
One publisher told Digiday, “The widgets are worth paying attention to. But it depends on what the goal is, scale or loyalty. If you’re about scale, then these widgets are important. But if you’re about loyalty, then they’re not nearly as important and it’s just another acquisition channel.”
Newsletter publishers cautiously plan to expand editorial and sales teams
Publishers with newsletter-focused businesses are looking to grow their editorial and sales teams this year — but cautiously, to keep spending down during a time of economic uncertainty.
Magna 2023 forecast paints a resilient U.S. market, thanks to retail media and streaming
In its latest ad forecast, Magna is expecting a resilient U.S. market this year – boosted by retail, streaming and the auto industry’s bounceback.
How agencies are shaping the future of DEI beyond their own walls
Agencies are acknowledging that diversity efforts don’t stop with their companies. In addition to improving employee representation, now agency efforts in diversity, equity and inclusion are aimed at supporting clients and external partners.
SponsoredHow advertisers are fostering more effective publisher partnerships
Michael Weaver, senior vice president, business development and growth, Al Jazeera Media Network An everyday conversation between publishers and advertisers goes like this: The publisher invites the advertiser to a meal to talk about their business, attempts to delve into specifics on what the media buyer is looking to achieve, their audience breakdown and how […]
Newsletter publishers say they continue to see uptick in revenue despite advertising slowdown
At a time when larger media companies are feeling the pressure of the economic downturn and advertising slowdown, newsletter businesses continue to be in a period of revenue growth.
TikTok’s CEO faces bipartisan skepticism in first Congressional hearing on security concerns
The hearing comes amid calls to remove TikTok from government devices and in some cases even ban it entirely.