Which native ad disclosed itself best?
Publishers still have a lot of work to do before their sponsored content disclosures are up to snuff.
While publishers are producing and running sponsored content in greater numbers, one thing they haven’t figured out is how to effectively label their output. Some publishers are particularly overt about it, while others are content with making readers work a little bit harder. And no one’s quite sure which approach works best.
The real challenge is that a lot of those disclosures may not be all that effective. A new study from analytics platform Nudge found that the most common native ad disclosures are actually the least effective at helping readers identify their content as ads. Sponsored content using disclosure techniques like the home page buyout (used, for example, by The Wall Street Journal) and the persistent disclosure banner (used by Slate) were only identified as ads by readers 29 percent of the time.
In contrast, Nudge found that over half of the 100 people it polled were able to to identify ads that featured disclosures within the content itself. In-content disclosures are rare compared to the other techniques, though.
Nudge’s conclusion: Some publishers may be going out of their way to label sponsored content, but readers are barely noticing them, thanks to banner blindness and small labeling. Ben Young, CEO of Nudge, said that this is more than publishers staying honest in the eyes of the FTC. Bad disclosure can actually hurt brands, too. “Effective disclosures mean effective brand recall,” he said.
Indeed, native ad disclosures at most publishers, including big ones like The New York Times, are still works in progress. In August, six months after introducing its first paid post from Dell, The New York Times made some big disclosure design changes, largely decreasing the sponsored content visual cues. While its initial Dell post was surrounded by a thick blue border and text that read “Paid For And Posted By Dell,” more recent sponsored stories from Netflix and Chevron have both come with smaller branding and much smaller blue borders as well.
BuzzFeed, too, has tweaked its formula. In May, the site removed the yellow shading surrounding the the sponsored content on its home page. It has also replaced the “presented by” and “BuzzFeed partner” labels in favor of those that say “promoted by” and “brand publisher.” Chris Johanesen, BuzzFeed’s vp of product said at the time, that the the goal was to “create the best experience for our readers and best product for our clients.”
It’s easy to understand publishers’ hesitation toward overly disclosing the brands sponsoring their content. A recent poll by content marketing company Contently found that two-thirds of readers felt tricked when they clicked on sponsored content, and over half of readers said that they don’t trust sponsored content at all.
Still, publishers say that it’s important that their brand partners and readers are on the same page. “No one — brands or publishers — is in the business of tricking readers,” said Josh Sternberg, content strategist at The Washington Post (and a former Digiday employee). “That said, labeling as you and I both know could be stronger across the industry — from font size to different shading, et cetera.”
Young said that critics who say that, on the sponsored content front, publishers are still balancing the needs of the readers with those of their advertisers. “They want to be upfront, the advertisers want it to be read, and the readers want the best experience,” he said.
‘Culture change takes years’: Facing ongoing calls for DE&I gains, publishers set new standards for hiring practices
The media industry is trying to solve a long-standing challenge: it is mostly white and male. Here's how some publishers are doing it.
Meet the ‘absolutist’ with the Section 230 tattoo on Google’s new misinformation policy team
Part of a nascent government affairs and public policy team at Google, Jess Miers is a die-hard fan of the 26-word law that gives legal cover to big tech platforms.
‘A perfect time for someone like me to be in this role’: Maria Reeve is breaking barriers at the Houston Chronicle
Maria Reeve didn’t set out to become the first person of color to oversee the Houston Chronicle’s newsroom. But now that she is, she’s making it count.
SponsoredHow retailers can be ready for holiday shoppers this year
Suchi Sastri, managing director and partner, Boston Consulting Group As the holiday season approaches and the pandemic continues to evolve, retailers want to know what to expect. Will e-commerce continue to grow at the rate it did last year? How big of a role will in-store shopping play in holiday shopping? While it’s still early, […]
Maven rebrands to The Arena Group and reorganizes around sports and finance
The Arena Group owns and hosts the domains of over 200 sites and generated $143 million in revenue for the year ending June 30, 2021.
‘Quit your f – king job’: How the pandemic has pushed journalists to exit the industry
The pandemic seems to be pushing journalists who were already on the verge of leaving the media industry to the brink, and those that have left are not looking back.