Counterpoint: Web Video Need Not be the Wild West

A recent Digiday article compared the online video advertising industry to the “Wild West,” citing questionable online video practices from networks and “rogue publishers” and how agencies are risking their clients’ reputations by buying ad inventory on sites they’ve never visited.

Online video doesn’t have to be a risky proposition in lawless territory. It is possible, however, to successfully navigate the Wild West of online video advertising and achieve maximum gain by making sure every campaign includes these important components.Most online video buys today are not very strategic and use dart board-style, run-of-site or run-of-category content. Nevertheless, success starts and ends with the existing “premium” portion of the buy. It is also the area with the highest out-of-pocket cost. Additional challenges include limited inventory and typical under-delivery. Premium content hidden within ad networks provides a similar audience, significantly greater reach and lower CPM than a publisher direct-only buy. The content itself, rather than who delivers it, is essential to video advertising success.

For the most accurate campaigns, advertisers should use in-stream video targeting. Media buyers need to see what is within the video and go far beyond the text and static images around the video to be able to effectively identify and classify within the video itself. Knowing where all the ads are running eliminates the threat of potential damage to the brand from inadvertently advertising on inappropriate content. In-stream video targeting also exposes previously unclassified content as premium content, which saves money.

Advertisers should leverage existing investments in their media partners for maximum campaign scale. Start with a catalyst, which in this case is an existing traditional media buy (online and broadcast, if applicable). Media buyers should determine where they are already advertising to enhance their brand. Next, extend the targeting criteria to video by specifying key attributes within the existing media buy. What are the programs and/or themes the brand is already aligning with? Are there any specific actors, objects or products within the content that the brand wants to identify?

An online video ad campaign cannot be considered successful without measuring effectiveness. Brands want proof that the targeting method works before committing to future campaigns. Fortunately, several measurement options exist, including viewer engagement, video ad completion rates, the ability to track where the ads run and audience demographics, among others. Using these measurement options, advertisers can be sure their campaigns are running according to plan and can rework their targeting options mid-campaign if necessary to get back on track.

Mike Sullivan is CEO of Affine, a contextual ad targeting platform for online video.

More in Media

The Rundown: Google has drawn its AI payment lines — and publishers’ leverage is narrow

For publishers trying to navigate AI licensing, the message was blunt: Google is willing to pay for access, but not for training – and it remains unwilling to define AI Overviews as a compensable use of journalism.

search referral traffic for publishers

Media Briefing: Google’s latest core update a reminder that pageviews can’t remain the primary metric

Google’s latest core update signals pageviews can no longer be the primary metric, favoring intent-solving publishers over scale.

After an oversaturation of AI-generated content, creators’ authenticity and ‘messiness’ are in high demand

Content creators and brand marketing specialists on how 2026 will be the year creator authenticity becomes even more crucial in the face of rampant AI-generated “slop” flooding social media platforms.