Why ‘acceptable’ ads are no silver bullet for ad blocking
When it comes to multi-party efforts to clean up an industry, conflicts are the norm, not the exception.
AdBlock Plus assembled members of 15-odd publishers, agencies and industry groups for a private dinner on Tuesday night to dish on the future of ad blocking. On the agenda: hashing out the details about the company’s “acceptable ads” board, an independent industry-wide body that will help figure out which ads will make it past AdBlock Plus’s filters.
While AdBlock Plus parent company Eyeo insists that it’s using its ad blocking clout to clean up the Web, the company has been dogged by claims that it’s built its business model around extorting publishers and advertising companies. While the majority of companies added to its whitelist got there free of charge, 70 others, including, according to reports, Google and Taboola had to pay for the privilege. The IAB has called the model “highway robbery.”
“There does feel like there’s misaligned incentive,” said Ari Rosenberg, president of IPC Pricing. “When you think about it, what they really want is for more bad ads to be served, so more people join their universe.”
That conflict of interest, whether real or perceived, has complicated the narrative that the ad blocking problem can best be solved by companies whose bottom lines are tied to its outcome. Eyeo’s vision is to create an independent body of ad tech companies, publishers, and browser makers to approve additions to the list free of external influence, even its own. But when it comes to such schemes, conflicts are inevitable. A company such as Google might champion the rights of Web users when it comes to their right to install ad blocking software, but would be less enthusiastic about how those rights hurt its core advertising business.
Craig Spiezle, executive director of The Online Trust alliance, said that the industry’s vexation over ad blocking mirrors the mood of paranoia in the email marketing world circa 2004, when email marketers cried foul over their messages being filtered by Internet companies. That created a market for companies such as Return Path, which added marketers to its certified whitelist in exchange for an annual fee. GoodMail Systems, which shut down in 2011, charged marketers for each email they wanted push messages through email filters.
Industry-wide attempts to define what is and isn’t acceptable are also likely to fall victim to the general squishiness of the word “acceptable.” AdBlock Plus currently says an ad is acceptable if it’s static, text-only, clearly marked and doesn’t interfere with or distract from the browsing experience. The definition has its limits, however. Taboola’s recommended content widget, for example, which AdBlock Plus says is an acceptable format, hasn’t been accepted by members of AdBlock Plus’s forums, who say that the format regularly violates their idea of what should be acceptable.
“Is it really enough that ad fits in naturally and isn’t intrusive, or should ‘acceptable’ also mean the ad is truthful and isn’t trying to trick users?” said Dan Greenberg, CEO of Sharethrough. “There’s a case to be made that we should be looking at this from the standpoint that the user should be the one defining what’s acceptable and what isn’t.”
Pinterest testing new co-sold, revenue-share ad model for publishers with Tastemade
Currently in an experimental phase, Tastemade is the first publisher to sign on and the brand that is funding this ad experiment is corn chip snack Fritos.
As publishers clean up automated supply chains, education-title Chegg cut ad resellers and saw no negative impact on revenue
"We were told as publishers that resellers were so important, but no [publisher] has communicated to me they removed resellers and lost X% lift."
Member ExclusiveThe Facebook ad boycott could help publishers swing the pendulum back to context
Publishers have a golden opportunity to shift thinking around the role context, broadly defined, should play in advertising.
SponsoredFour ways to adapt to the changing publisher ecosystem in 2020
By Neal Sinno, general manager Americas at GeoEdge For marketers, 2020 started out with so much promise — but this changed rapidly as the industry faced a global epidemic head-on. Not only did our own daily routines come to a screeching halt, for many of us our professional lives did as well. Almost as quickly […]
Patagonia: Boycotting Facebook ads will lead to an ‘even more thoughtful approach’ to its ad buying
Patagonia has pulled all paid ads from Facebook and Instagram until at least the end of July. The boycott will extend if the advertiser has seen three specific changes to how the social network handles hate speech.
How Substack has spawned a new class of newsletter entrepreneurs
As the media ecosystem contracts amid coronavirus, Substack has been thrust into an uncomfortable role — that of a savior.