AI Marketing Strategies | NYC

Register by Jan 13 to save on passes and connect with marketers from Uber, Bose and more

SECURE SEAT

Video: WTF is bid shading?

This article is a WTF explainer, in which we break down media and marketing’s most confusing terms. More from the series →

As the programmatic auction model continues to evolve, so do the problems that come with it. Here, senior reporter Tim Peterson discusses the many iterations of this ad buying process, and both the good and the bad sides of its newest development: bid shading.

The key hits:

  • Programmatic auctions in their traditional second-price auction, would allow the highest bidder to only pay slightly more than the second-highest bid. This has given way to a first-price auction model, most notably used by Google’s ad exchange.
  • In a first-price auction model advertisers often find themselves on the losing end, due to the fact that they must pay the price that they bid, rather than just slightly higher than the bid that they beat. This led to the development of bid shading, where ad tech companies try to predict the highest bid, so companies aren’t bidding too much.
  • Bid shading does appear to be working. According to companies like PubMatic and The Trade Desk, both of which offer bid shading, advertisers are paying an average of 20% less on their bids.
  • The way that bid shading currently works creates a lot of opportunity for ad tech companies to take advantage of advertisers looking to score a deal. Since advertisers aren’t privy to the information that the ad tech companies are using to predict, they don’t know how inflated the numbers that they’re seeing are. This creates a loophole where ad tech companies may tell advertisers to pay higher prices, and pocket the difference, without advertisers’ knowledge.

To watch more videos from Digiday, head to our YouTube channel.

More in Marketing

What does media spend look like for 2026? It could be worse — and it might be

Forecasts for 2026 media spend range from 6.6% on the lower end to over 10% but the primary beneficiaries will be commerce, social and search.

Pitch deck: How Amazon is emerging as the proof layer for TV spend

Amazon is positioning itself to advertisers as the “first-stop shop” for planning, buying, optimizing and measuring TV.

Here are the 2025 brand winners and losers of tariffs

Tariffs completely upended the retail industry in 2025 — and no company was left unscathed.