Plenty of folks are using AMC’s “The Pitch” to debate the merits of how new business in our industry is won. To adequately review the show, the better question to me is what is our motivation to watch? Is it a show that we should study— or simply an escape to enjoy. If we’re supposed to learn how to pitch, then I’ll argue the show teaches terrible lessons.
In the Subway first episode, for example, the better idea didn’t win, yet a terrible presentation did. And in last night’s competition between The Ad Store and SK+G, originality—a touchstone for many of us—didn’t seem to count in the end. Entertainment, however, is the purpose of reality shows, whether you’re a fashion designer, a chef, or a creative exec spouting clichés. The job of “The Pitch” is to keep us gripped for an hour a week and get us to tune in (or DVR) again, so even with the flaws of this week, I’m still in.
Last night, Las Vegas agency SK+G and New York’s The Ad Store squared off to build awareness of how client Waste Management transforms trash to energy. “We do so much more than garbage,” a client bragged in the straightforward briefing. As most of us probably recognize, nearly every assignment nowadays seems to be about energy or jobs with the hope that our idea will “go viral.”
If you love drama, there was the suspense of what ideas each team would propose and which in the end would win. If you’re an old-time “Dynasty” fanatic like I am, you were disappointed at the lack of Krystal and Alexis cat fights. Instead you had to suffer through SK+G internal sparring, including cringe-worthy, passive-aggressive tension between co-creative directors. Ick. This was different from the sneak preview since McKinney and WWDC both seemed more unified, more polished and more experienced at pitches. The agencies’ proposed campaigns were hardly shocking. SK+G developed “Garbage is Good,” and The Ad Store presented “Trash Can” (the word ‘can’ as a verb as well as noun). With less than six days to work, it’d be arrogant to presume you’d do much better. Interestingly, they both had the same insight, although Ad Store’s tagline and on-street executions seemed stronger. Of course, both did a manifesto. We love manifestos.
If you’re looking for authenticity, you could find plenty. There was the initial briefing: SK+G telling the clients their city is beautiful (Houston?) and that their product has infectious passion. There was the competitive idea generation and politics back home. Researching and bad-mouthing the competition rang true too, along with the final presentation technical glitches that didn’t end up mattering. What was glaring, however, was the total absence of strategy, which doubly annoys me since half my household does this for a living. No unique or provocative insights worth sharing? None?
All the time spent on agency soul searching, though, wasn’t real to me. Sure, most agencies navel-gaze, but it’s usually about how amazingly clean their navel is, not self-doubt and teary-eyed mush like we saw.
I bet the big takeaway for most viewers is that the winner of a pitch like this is the idea the client simply likes the most. What bugs me is that, since I started in advertising 20 years ago, I’ve believed that the client buys an agency and its people; the idea is a sample of how we think and work. This might no longer be true. More and more, I’ve noticed that pitch work actually becomes the produced work. Perhaps it’s the need for speed to market. So they really aren’t buying just us, they’re buying our ideas. And for those of you who don’t obsess over award shows, some of last night’s pitch work may have been unintentionally real a year ago. SK+G’s app combining print and mobile — the social media idea that helped the agency “nail” it and win the night— wasn’t original or bold. Reporters Without Borders did the same application more elegantly last spring, garnering a slew of awards. Perhaps the client doesn’t know or care. But we do. And we desperately want to think originality wins.
Will I watch again? It’s a bit early in the show’s life to jump the shark, although it started to go there with the personality deep-dives on various characters. The fixation on Bob’s smoking. The crying toddler in Las Vegas. Still, I wish I had dramatic music following me around like that.
Mat Zucker is a creative director, marketer and essayist in New York. Follow him on Twitter @matzucker
Marketing Briefing: U.S. marketers prepare contingency plans amid potential TikTok ban
The likelihood of a ban is still up in the air, marketers and agency execs say, which is why some are simply taking a wait and see approach while others are preparing contingency plans.
In graphic detail: Gamers are warming up to in-game ads
Comscore questioned gamers about their attitudes toward advertisements in games for its State of Gaming report. Digiday got a sneak peek.
Digiday+ Research deep dive: Agency spending on TikTok plateaus as brands struggle with what to make of the app
Agency clients' spending on TikTok may have hit a plateau, while brand marketers are still searching for the right answer when it comes to how much confidence they should have in the platform.
SponsoredBrands are optimizing video production to drive user acquisition
Sponsored by QuickFrame by MNTN With brands increasingly investing in video ads on social media, marketers are enhancing their video production capabilities to unlock growth on Facebook and Instagram. Especially urgent in an uncertain economic climate, brands must minimize production costs while creating a high enough volume of social media videos to identify the creative […]
WTF is a data clean room?
Platforms use data clean rooms in order to share aggregated audience data versus user-level data.
Meta, Snapchat, Twitter layoffs spell trouble for agency relationships
The speed and scale of platform layoffs only compound the problem of marketers feeling neglected by the social media giants.