In Defense of Banner Ads
Ben Kunz is vice president of strategic planning at media agency Mediassociates. Follow him on Twitter @benkunz.
If you believe banners suck, you’re not alone. The poor things are so disparaged that the entire digital industry has repositioned them as display advertising to wipe off the banner stigma.
But the truth is, banner ads work just as well as most other forms of media, which is remarkable given their small size, surrounding clutter and creative limitations. So let’s do something that people in media rarely do: compare banners to other forms of media, using the same yardstick of response rates.
First, banner click-through rates are only 0.07 percent. Yes, display advertising CTRs have fallen for years, stabilizing recently around 0.07 percent. Within digital ad formats, some CTRs are lower (Facebook ads hover around 0.03 percent) and others higher (rich media gets noticed). Industry reports from the DMA or Google vary, espousing CTR averages from 0.03 percent to 0.09 percent, but the 0.07 percent figure is the one critics usually scoff at. Yeah, that’s low. But how does it compare to other media?
TV has a 0.05 percent response rate. Look at that giant screen; you’d think it would pull a higher response. But there may be a reason television plays to its own set of metrics — GRPs, anyone? Because its actual response rate is lower than banner ads. According to Nielsen, the typical U.S. consumer is exposed to 4 hours and 38 minutes of TV a day, about 40 percent of which is commercial time. This works out to 110 ad minutes, or 220 30-second spots per day, for 6,600 total TV commercials hitting each viewer per month. Let’s be generous and assume you rush out to explore three products you see advertised on TV each month. Three divided by 6,600 equals a 0.05 percent response rate.
Radio nets 0.13 percent. Barely better. Arbitron, let’s peer beyond reach and frequency. U.S. consumers listen to 1 hour and 23 minutes of radio each day, which rolls up to 2,500 minutes per month. Radio pushes nine minutes of commercials per hour — 15 percent of all air time — resulting in 375 minutes of ads, or 750 30-second spots per month. Since you use radio only one-third as much as TV, let’s assume you respond to one product advertised on radio each month. One inquiry divided by 750 spots equals a 0.13 percent response.
Let’s play the math one more time with outdoor. If a marketer wants to hit the New York City suburbs hard with billboards, she’d spend about $320,000 for 26 large 14-by-48-foot billboards (for a 50 GRP level). That provides 28.2 million impressions a month. If our marketer is selling cars and wants a $200 cost per sale, she needs 1,600 sales. If only 20 percent of respondents buy, she needs 8,000 respondents. 8,000 divided by 28.2 million impressions is a 0.03 percent response rate.
You get the picture. Most advertising stinks in terms of response, because consumers dodge ads whenever they can. Response rates across all media regress to an average where more than 99.9 percent of all ads in any channel are ignored. But that’s OK because advertising is a game of what we catch, not what we spill. If each response generates an acceptable cost per sale, we reach a groovy little thing called advertising ROI, and all the waste fades away.
So stop disparaging banner ads, people. They perform only as poorly as your beloved TV spots and blaring radio. Given that these tiny digital boxes must compete with short films with $200,000 budgets or rich audio, it’s a wonder banners work so well at all.
As brands test Amazon’s direct link between digital ads and Whole Foods purchases, they spot new data nuggets — and gaps
Advertisers are using Amazon's recently-launched attribution feature to see how digital ads drive real-life purchases at Whole Foods.
‘I don’t think their outlook is dire’: Why a return to in-person events hasn’t deterred marketers on Clubhouse
Even with vaccine rollout and a return to in-person events, marketers still see the value in Clubhouse communities formed during the coronavirus pandemic.
Some agencies are giving summer Fridays a second look so employees can ‘enjoy their life again’
Agency executives say that the increased focus on taking advantage of summer Fridays this year is to help employees take the time they need to relax, improve mental health after a difficult year and avoid burnout.
SponsoredHow The Company Store is reimagining customer experiences for pandemic-era growth
Throughout the pandemic, some retail categories have been inherently successful. Home furnishings and décor are among them; with consumers spending so much more time at home, updates and renovations flourished. Criteo data from the first half of 2020 showed sales for items like outdoor furniture sets up 434% year over year, with other home items […]
‘Bridge the gap between paid and organic’: Why Reddit is building an in-house agency to work with brands
Reddit is building an in-house creative strategy agency, KarmaLab, in a broader bid in recent years to grow its ads business.
Cheat Sheet: Why Roblox is fast becoming one of the most important media businesses of the future
Gamers spent 9.7 billion hours on Roblox in the first three months of the year. Here's a look at how the company became one of the most important media businesses of the future.