When Kevin Porter joined creative shop Walrus as the head of its media department this month, one of his big tasks was building a team to manage media buying, planning and strategy for the agency’s clients. He’s also hiring digital media strategists to bolster its programmatic expertise. Having media in-house will help the creative team better understand media channels, user behavior, content and context.
“If you don’t bring media in-house, you only provide half of the service to clients,” said Frances Webster, co-founder and chief operating officer for Walrus.
Other creative agencies including Droga5 and Wieden+Kennedy have started offering services to bridge the gap between creative and media. But analysts and media agency executives question how far those shops can take their media services.
Wieden+Kennedy began taking on media duties back in 1995. Droga5 has offered media-planning services since last October. Around 15 of the 33 people on Droga5’s communications strategy team do media planning for clients. To date, Droga5 has done complete media planning for five clients, said Colleen Leddy, head of communications strategy at Droga5.
“Context is becoming as important as content,” said Leddy. “Communications strategy decides how and when a creative plan rolls out, while media planning determines exactly where the idea [appears].”
In contrast to Walrus, Droga5 doesn’t plan to get into media buying anytime soon, as some media channels still rely on scale and volume, said Leddy. Media is moving toward programmatic, which transforms rapidly, and Droga5 doesn’t want to build an infrastructure that could become outdated in a few years.
“Ad viewability and transparency also have some struggles right now, which is a pretty significant challenge,” she said.
Kamran Asghar, CEO of media agency Crossmedia, said there are a few reasons creative shops would want to move media in-house. For instance, clients want to know who they are targeting and where before deciding how to approach creative. Meanwhile, media agencies have visibility and greater control over the investment and the data, which drive communications decisions, said Asghar. But creative agencies may underestimate the complexity of media planning and buying.
“Media requires deep understanding of first-party, second-party and third-party data, as well as advanced measurement solutions that link individual customers to outputs or experiences,” said Asghar. “Buying media also requires a mix of human-powered negotiations and machine-powered buying.”
He added that taking on media services comes with tremendous risks, including ad fraud, viewability issues, overspending and sequential liability.
Brian Wieser, senior research analyst for Pivotal, said he doubted creative agencies bringing media in-house was a meaningful trend. Some clients that left holding group agencies for independent creative shops like Droga5, Wieden+Kennedy and 72andSunny may also want integrated media, but fewer advertisers are willing to pay for top-tier creative because of internal pressure to keep costs down.
“In general, the global networks [take a share of] total media spending activity because they have been able to buy media much more cheaply,” Wieser said. “There could be some marketers who might shift media out of the global media agencies, but I haven’t seen much tangible evidence.”
In Walrus’ case, Webster said the agency doesn’t intend to compete with media shops in ad pitches. “If Walrus works on a large client’s roster and there’s already a media agency, we are happy to serve as a creative agency,” she said. “Several clients came to us recently asking for [media offerings] — brands with $1 [million] to $10 million marketing budgets are looking for a one-stop shop.”
A typo in an earlier version of this story mistakenly said brands with $1 million to $2 million in budget were looking for a one-stop shop. It has been reflected to say $10 million. Meanwhile, Wieden+Kennedy said that it started taking on media duties back in 1995, not 2013 as originally stated in the story. Digiday regrets the errors.
In-game advertising experts question Microsoft and Sony’s gaming advertising plans
The importance of free-to-play titles is one reason why some in-game advertising experts are skeptical about the tech giants’ ability to succeed in their chosen business.
‘A lot of these brands need a reality check’: Confessions of a PR agency founder on agency ‘jumpers’ and tense client-agency relationships
Confessions of a PR agency founder on agency 'jumpers' and tense client-agency relationships.
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: ‘This is a better way to travel’: Q&A with Airbnb’s global head of marketing on the company’s new capabilities, in-housing
Digiday caught up with Hiroki Asai to chat about the changes as well as Airbnb’s approach to marketing.
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
The vast majority of marketers are unhappy with their Customer Data Platforms, but then again, not many are sure what they really are
Marketers are confused by tech vendors', well, marketing as the requirement for complexity grows
How the layoffs at Upcomer show the challenges of public ownership in esports media
Enthusiast’s lack of a seemingly cohesive strategy for Upcomer is a reflection of the broader challenges it faces as a gaming and esports holding company that is, at the moment, one of the few publicly traded firms in the industry.