Madison Avenue has more than a little Silicon Valley envy. There’s a feeling that as the ad world struggles to put in place less cumbersome processes in the face of the rapidly changing digital media world it is just falling farther behind.
AKQA’s chief creative officer Rei Inamoto has been vocal on the issue, arguing that creativity no longer belongs to those with the word “creative” in their job titles and that some of the most innovative ideas of the past decade have been coming from what are typically regarded as “non-creative” people, such as engineers and technologists. Inamoto last week expanded his views during an Internet Week event at AKQA’s New York offices.
Views among the quartet were mixed. Boone and Wheeler’s answer to the question was a resounding yes, and both argued startup-like thinking among agencies will not only be beneficial to their businesses, but ultimately essential for their survival.
“The agency world can learn from Silicon Valley’s notion of agility, elasticity, and launch and iterate,” said Torrence Boone, a former ad executive, who is now Google’s director of agency development. “The way the Valley operates can inform the way agencies go to market and allow them to be more responsive and effective in today’s world.”
Just as many startups embrace the idea of a minimum viable product, agencies should think about the concept of “minimum viable ideas,” which are, he suggested, pushed to market as quickly as possible and then iterated upon. That’s a far cry from the typical agency approach that often revolves around a “big idea” and subsequently involves months of strategy, theory and rationalization before anything gets to market.
“There’s way too much risk-aversion in the industry. At Google, we have this idea that if you’re going to fail, do it fast. The way you do that is by launching and iterating, and getting concrete data so you know how to course-correct.”
Eric Wheeler, a former top Ogilvy exec and later a tech startup founder with social targeting firm 33Across, noted agencies aren’t incentivized to be efficient thanks to their compensation models. Staff within agencies want to innovate, but their “aircraft-like” nature makes it difficult to do, he said.
“The business models are evolving,” he said. “Startups take a really good look at the landscape and focus on the problems out there they can solve. I believe agencies have to think this way to survive.”
Easier said than done, noted former BBH chairman Cindy Gallop. Though she agreed that agencies need to change, they should think less about emulating startups and more about how they can recalibrate their businesses to take advantage of the opportunities that they present.
“Agencies should reinvent themselves and take influence from the startup world to do that,” she said. “The knee-jerk startup business model is ad funded, but there aren’t enough advertisers to go around. That represents a huge opportunity for our industry. These companies hate us, but they need us. I think the future is better collaboration between agencies and startups.”
Venture capitalist Charlie O’Donnell took a similar stance, arguing that agencies should ultimately stick to what they do best and to what they’re staffed to achieve. He pointed to the fundamental differences between the outlook and nature of agencies versus startups. Agencies sell: It’s a service-based business in which they’re required to be constantly coming up with new ideas in order to earn a crust.
Because of that, they invest their time and efforts more wisely than most startups, he suggested, party because of their intimate knowledge of the needs and problems facing brands and advertisers.
“I don’t think startups always do a good job of chasing after right problems,” he said. “Agencies, because they’re so sales driven, don’t spend time building things for six months that advertisers have been saying for a year they don’t need.”
The Rundown: Meta to put new ads all over Facebook and Instagram, including on user profiles
Meta is launching new ad formats this quarter, which are hoping to capitalize off of readers' appetite for discovery.
Productivity app Notion goes global with OOH efforts
As productivity app Notion expands its business, it is ramping up global OOH efforts to get in front of shoppers across the world.
Member ExclusiveDigiday+ Research: Facebook, Instagram, YouTube valued by brands and agencies, but ad spend lags — especially on TikTok
Brands and agencies are in alignment in terms of how confident they are that social media drives marketing success, but a significant gap exits between how they allocate marketing budgets on those platforms.
SponsoredHow FAST channels are redefining primetime opportunities for advertisers
Sponsored by Vevo With the competition from content providers continuing to build, the traditional primetime TV slots are no longer guaranteeing the mass audiences they once did. Television viewership is evolving, and the primetime window of 8–11 p.m. is less broadly reflective of younger audiences’ content consumption habits. In 2022, attracting TV viewers is a […]
4A’s Marla Kaplowitz on 3 ways agencies can navigate the uncertain economy
The industry trade group is helping many agency members prepare their business for broader economic changes, from how to retain talent to honing their financial acumen.
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: Marketers, agencies report it’s ‘the perfect storm’ as new business pitches slow
The second and third quarters of this year were slower than usual for pitches, according to agency execs, who said there's a sense of pullback across the board from marketers this year.