Why agencies screw up content marketing
Chris Boyles used to work for mega agencies Razorfish and Digitas. He recently joined Chaotic Moon, a creative tech studio in Austin, Texas.
“Your brief is showing.” That’s what people in advertising say when you’re a little too on strategy. Too often, the agencies are thinking about what the client wants, not what the audience wants.
I should know: I worked as a copywriter and creative director for 16 years and, most of the time, was just asked to tick boxes off a list. This was especially egregious at big corporate agencies, where the focus was on billings and not ideas.
Ultimately, this “garbage in, garbage out” approach sent me packing. I ended up working for startups and, soon after, started dabbling in content marketing. During my time in advertising, I won only three awards. Yet in the year or so I’ve been a content marketer, I’ve won seven awards — plus recognition from Communication Arts and Digiday. Did I suddenly become a better writer? While I’d love to say yes, I know that’s not true. So what changed? My approach.
It’s about the audience, not the client.
The fundamental difference between content marketing and advertising is this: Only the latter should be created with the intent to sell something immediately. Content marketing is that slow burn that predisposes audiences to a product or service, making them more likely to act when faced with sales-y communications later. As such, this isn’t where you talk about your client’s value prop — this is where you zero in on what’s important to your audience. Don’t know it? Find out. You won’t need anything as formal as a focus group. You can get answers, sometimes even enlightening ones, simply by posing questions on social media. Conducting a listening audit isn’t a bad idea either.
Take American Express. Only about 1 percent of the content on the Open Forum is about American Express. The platform is instead used to advise small businesses on operations, finance and marketing.
Think in terms of earned, not paid.
Agencies are used to paying for placement, so it’s hard for them to think about creating something a media outlet would run solely on its own merits. Sure, you can pay for a sponsored-content placement, but that doesn’t mean it will get watched or read. I tend to use editors as my B.S. meter — if they’re excited about something, it’s likely their audience will be too. It’s harder to gauge the relative quality when you’re merely cutting a check. What I’ve learned from copious amounts of pitching: Media outlets are most excited when you propose something they either haven’t seen or can’t produce themselves. More than once, I ended up with great exposure for my content and didn’t have to pay a dime.
Chipotle believes in sustainability in a way many of its competitors do not. Chipotle’s second short film perfectly reflects its philosophy — in a way that’s incredibly compelling. Major media attention meant over 11 million views.
Strategy is just as important as execution.
Many agencies take a “ready, shoot, aim” approach when it comes to getting work out the door. And given advertising’s incredibly short shelf life, it’s no wonder shops have no qualms about banging it out. Content marketing, however, has the potential to endure. So make sure you can live with whatever you create, as it’s likely going to be around a while. To ensure there are no regrets, take the time to figure out what makes sense, come up with a solid plan, and then deliver, deliver, deliver. There’s always room for improvement, but it’s best not to assume that in the beginning.
Intel isn’t the sexiest brand, but its collaboration with Vice, The Creators Project, has attracted over 400,000 subscribers since 2010.
When you take all of this into consideration, is it even possible for ad agencies to do content marketing well? Of course. It’ll just require their employees to forget most of what they’ve been told. I did it and you can, too.
Image via Shutterstock
‘Influencer deals are being paused’: As Facebook boycott begins in earnest, influencer marketing feels a sting
The latest move to pause influencer marketing comes as marketers are not only reconsidering where their ads appear and the kind of content they appear next to, but as they work to figure out how they can better support Black creators and Black-owned businesses following the Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests.
As Facebook boycott continues, here’s a look at what major marketers were spending on Facebook and Instagram
To get a sense of how much advertisers are pulling back from Facebook, Digiday reached out to ad-tracking firm Pathmatics. The company provided estimates for how much advertisers spent on the platform during July 2019 as well as from July 2019 to 2020.
Member Exclusive‘Performative posting’: As agencies share their equality values online, staffers say they have to do much more for Black employees than post
Agency employees and execs say agencies need to do more than make statements to be better for Black employees.
SponsoredFour ways to adapt to the changing publisher ecosystem in 2020
By Neal Sinno, general manager Americas at GeoEdge For marketers, 2020 started out with so much promise — but this changed rapidly as the industry faced a global epidemic head-on. Not only did our own daily routines come to a screeching halt, for many of us our professional lives did as well. Almost as quickly […]
‘Don’t want to piss off customers’: With manufacturing and exporting snarled, some DTC brands are adapting their advertising
Media buyers say that supply chain hiccups have caused them to pause or significantly reduce media spending anywhere from two weeks to five weeks for some DTC brands low on product inventory.
Beyond remote work: Bringing serendipity back to the office
This article is part of the Future of Work briefing, a weekly email with stories, interviews, trends and links about how work, workplaces and workforces are changing. Sign up here. Kai Micah Mills had been working in a different state from his work partner for years. More recently, though, his partner, Ben Adamsky, made the move […]