Would Media Buyers Embrace an Upfront Video Market?

Given the excitement over this year’s NewFront, there’s a burning question around whether digital inventory ever will become the norm, rather than the exception, for selling digital video.

There’s a lot of speculation around whether there’s enough quality online video to support a full-fledged upfront market. But it’s also worth looking at the people who actually do the ad buying and asking how an upfront might fit into their world. So I’d like to ask a very specific question: How would media buyers take to an upfront digital video market?

Some pundits give a resounding no. Pivotal Research’s Brian Weiser, for instance, observes in a research note that “online advertising is typically planned closer to the time at which campaigns run,” and so “it just doesn’t require anything resembling an upfront marketplace.” Weiser has a good point. Digital buying — a world of real-time bidding and automated platforms — isn’t a business of long cycles.  And from search to email to last-click metrics, the prominence of direct marketing in the digital space makes buying inventory in hard-to-measure distant horizons, if not an anomaly, then a bit out of place.

Buying prime digital inventory is also notoriously complex. The decades-old TV industry has business standards and buying technologies that streamline interactions between buyers and sellers, but high-end digital buys typically happen through a frustrating string of emails, phone calls, and faxes (yes, faxes). That’s why an estimated 8-28 percent of the net cost of buying prime digital inventory goes to overhead from human back-and-forth between buyers and sellers — compared to an estimated 2 percent for TV. If you’re trying to create a format for quickly transacting on the most expensive inventory in the digital world, it doesn’t bode well if actually placing the buy feels like pulling teeth.

Another way here is to empowering traditional TV buyers to buy digital video inventory as freely as they buy television. After all, they’re the branding-focused buyers who think in the long term and have practices and systems at the ready for absorbing large inventory purchases. Through them, you shift the challenge to getting the sell side to the same level of standards and technology that the buy side already has, rather than starting everything from scratch. In other words, there are clear similarities between television and online video. Enough, you might say, that putting the same people in charge of buying both makes a fair degree of sense.

If TV buyers do want to get serious about digital inventory, they’ll need intelligent apples-to-apples comparisons of digital media and the traditional inventory they’ve been buying all along. The huge leaps forward we’ve seen this year in Digital GRP’s means we’re making real inroads on this problem. But a lot of media leaders still feel that digital GRP’s are too young a field to be practical on the day-to-day. There’s a need for better standards and technology in the online video market and also a need for cross-channel workflow tools.

So at the end of the day, does the digital upfront have a shot at becoming a new standard? Maybe, maybe not. But my point here hasn’t been to take a stand. I just hope that I could provide a small reminder that, if you want to see where the future of our industry lies, you need to understand how the people who make the future happen make the business work.

Harvey Kent is chief media strategist at Mediaocean, an advertising technology company.

Digiday Top Stories
  • Eyeview becomes the latest ad tech casualty

    Eyeview, which raised around $80 million in funding, told its 100 employees the company would shut.

  • Video: WTF is Apple’s privacy update?

    Digiday senior reporter Tim Peterson breaks down Apple's new privacy update.

    ad attribution
  • Online music videos get official age ratings in UK, the US could be next

    Online music videos will now receive age ratings in the same way films do in the U.K. as part of a government-led pilot. The Department of Culture Media and Sport has brought together U.K. record labels, Sony, Universal and Warner Music, along with platforms YouTube and Vevo, ratings body BBFC and record label trade body BPI to crack down on the amount of unsuitable music content seen by children online.

  • Content marketers share their biggest mistakes and failures

    At the Digiday Content Marketing Summit, in Half Moon Bay, California, this week, we asked the cream of the content marketing crop what to share their biggest mistakes. Hasbro's Tina Walsh likened a failed call for user-generated content to "throwing a party and no one comes." Sonic's Sarah Beddoe cautioned against jumping on the latest social platform just because it feels like everyone else is there.

  • Throwback Thursday: Nike ads just did it

    The words "Nike" and "advertising" are as likely to evoke super-star athletes -- from Michael Jordan to Tiger Woods -- as they are inspirational paeans to striving and sweating. But a look back at classic Nike ads this throwback Thursday reveals a few surprises. "Just do it," one of the all-time classic slogans, is as core to the Nike brand as the shoe itself. But the tag, created by Wieden+Kennedy co-founder Dan Wieden, didn't hit the air until 1988. Featuring a real-life octogenarian marathoner, the spot was completely celeb-free.